Microsoft 1. RBS 1 01RBS

User Manual: RBS 1

Open the PDF directly: View PDF PDF.
Page Count: 26

DownloadMicrosoft  - 1. RBS 1 01RBS
Open PDF In BrowserView PDF
1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium
19 April 2011

Hong Kong Market Outlook
- Implications of the CNH market
Woon Khien Chia
Head of Local Markets Strategy, Asia
The Royal Bank of Scotland
woonkhien.chia@rbs.com
tel. +65 6518 5169

Duncan Mansfield
Solutions Structurer
The Royal Bank of Scotland
duncan.mansfield@rbs.com
tel. +852 2966 2442

The CNH roadmap
China’s market liberalisation (2002-2008) – the early days
Dec 08
Feb 04

Jul 07

HK became a
offshore CNY
clearance
centre

2003

2004

CDB issued first
CNY-denominated
bond outside
China

2005

2006

2007

Dec 03

Jul 05

Jan 07

HK banks
allowed to
take CNY
deposits

CNY floated
and revalued
by 2%
against USD

China financial
institutions allowed
to issue CNY bonds
in HK

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

PBOC signed
bilateral currency
swap agreement
with Korea
(CNY180bn). First
of 8 swap lines

2008

2

The CNH roadmap
China’s market liberalisation (2009) – setting goal for CNY internationalisation
Mar 09
Jan 09
Currency swap
agreement with
HK
(CNY200bn)

Currency swap
agreements with
Argentina (CNY
70bn), Belarus
(CNY20bn) and
Indonesia (CNY10bn)

Sep 09
China issued its
first CNY
government bond
in HK

2009
Feb 09

Jun 09

Currency
swap
agreement
with Malaysia
(CNY80bn)

Trade settlement
scheme expanded to
allow settlement with
Hong Kong and
ASEAN nations

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

3

The CNH roadmap
China’s market liberalisation (2010-2011) – the Big Bang
Jan 11

Feb 10

Jul 10

HKMA allowed all
forms of CNYrelated fund
raising as long as
funds do not flow
back to mainland

PBOC and HKMA
signed Supplementary
Memorandum of
Cooperation – paved
way for setup of CNH
interbank market

Oct 10
HKMA took over
CNY clearing bank
role after BOC (HK)
exhausted its
conversion quota

PBOC launched pilot
programme to allow
qualified domestic
firms to use CNY for
outward direct
investments.

2010
Jun 10

Jun 10

CNY
returned to
appreciation
path, postLehamn
crisis

Trade settlement
scheme expanded
to allow settlement
globally

2011

Aug 10

Dec 10

Foreign central banks
with CNY swap lines,
clearing & settlement
banks for CNY trades
allowed to invest excess
CNY funds in onshore
interbank bond market,
subject to PBOC quota.

Number of onshore
firms eligible for
CNY trade
settlement was
increased from 365
to 67359

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

4

Potential of CNY as a world reserve currency
Share of world reserves – China vs. G3
60%

Share of world trade – China vs. US
16%

14%
50%
12%
40%
10%

30%

8%

6%
20%
4%
10%
2%

0%

0%
48 52 56 60 64 68 72 76 80 84 88 92 96 00 04 08
China

US

Japan

Euro Area

92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
China

US

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

5

CNY trade settlement scheme huge boost to CNH deposit base

Since initiation in Nov 09, banks have cumulatively settled CNY510bn worth of trade
600

- roughly 80% attributable to China’s imports, 20% from its exports

8

- Hong Kong and Singapore probably still key countries of import origins
500

7

CNY deposits in Hong Kong poised to reach CNY700-800bn by end-2011

6
400
5

300

4

3
200
2
100
1

0
Jul 09

0
Sep 09

Nov 09

CNY deposits in HK (% of deposits in HK, RHS)

Jan 10

Mar 10

May 10

Jul 10

Sep 10

Nov 10

Jan 11

CNY trade settlement (CNY bn, LHS)

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

6

New offshore CNY centres – potential competition for HK

Conditions for setting up an offshore
CNY centre
1.

Strong trade ties with China

2.

CNY swap line from PBOC

3.

Central clearing directly with PBOC

4.

Domestic currency traded in China’s
onshore interbank market
a.

b.

China interbank currently quotes
USD/CNY, EUR/CNY, JPY/CNY,
HKD/CNY, CNY/MYR, USD/SGD
PBOC said more foreign
currencies will be allowed to
trade as CNY crosses

PBOC's CNY swap lines
Date of
swap line
agreement

Size of swap
line (CNY bn)

% of
China's
total trade

Korea

Dec-08

180

7.0

Hong
Kong

Jan-09

200

7.8

Malaysia

Feb-09

80

2.5

Indonesia

Mar-09

100

1.4

Argentina

Mar-09

70

0.5

Belarus

Mar-09

20

0.07

Iceland

Jun-10

3.5

0.01

Jul-10

150

1.9

Singapore

Source: IMF, CEIC, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

7

Market anomaly 1: FX – CNH spot premium over onshore CNY
spot…
From peak of 2.5%, CNH spot premium over onshore CNY spot has narrowed to 0.05%
6.85

1700
1500

6.80

1300
6.75
1100
6.70

900

6.65

700
500

6.60

300
6.55
100
6.50

6.45
23 Aug 10

-100
-300
23 Sep 10

23 Oct 10

Spread (pips, RHS)

23 Nov 10
CNY spot

23 Dec 10

23 Jan 11

23 Feb 11

23 Mar 11

CNH spot

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

8

… leading to divergence in FX forward curves

FX forward markets – onshore, CNH and NDF

USD/CNY 1y forward – onshore vs. NDF
8.0

6.55
6.53

7.8

6.51

7.6

6.49

7.4

USD/CNY

6.47
7.2
6.45
7.0
6.43
6.41

6.8

6.39

6.6

6.37

6.4

6.35
Spot
Onshore CNY

1m
CNH

3m

6m

Tenors
Offshore NDF

12m

6.2
06

07

1y USD/CNY onshore

08

09

10

1y USD/CNY NDF

11
1y USD/CNH

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

9

Markets anomaly 2: interest rates – CNH yield curve differ in
both levels and directions from onshore swap curve…
CNH interest rate term structure vs. offshore ND-CCS, onshore IRS and CCS
4

4

3

3

2
2
1
1
0
0

-1

-1

-2

-2

-3

-3

-4
Jan
10

1y
CNH-CCS

2y

Onshore CNY CCS

3y
ND CCS
Onshore IRS

4y

5y

Mar
10

1y onshore CCS

May
10

Jul
10
1y ND-CCS

Sep
10

Nov
10

Jan
11

Mar
11

1y onshore IRS

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

10

… which led to huge premium of CNH bond issues over
onshore issues, including Chinese government issues
Sovereign benchmark curve set by China MOF CNH issues vs. onshore benchmark curve
4.5
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
2011

2012

2013

CNH government benchmark

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

Onshore government benchmark

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

11

The next phase – adding asset classes, expanding
geographical coverage
•Mini QFII Scheme
China’s domestic securities houses and fund managers to directly tap into overseas
investors to invest in onshore China bonds and equities

•CNY-denominated equity listing in HK
Listing CNY-denominated equities offshore; investors can exchange for CNY via liquidity
facility, with profits/ losses to be converted back into HKD

•Inward foreign direct investment settlement
Allowing foreign firms to bring offshore CNY funds into China for direct investments

•More offshore CNY centres
The 4 pre-requisites
a. strong trade flows with China
b. access to PBOC’s CNY swap line
c. CNY central clearing directly with PBOC
d. trading of offshore centre’s domestic currency in China interbank market

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

12

Implications of CNH on HKD
On HKD’s dollar peg

On HKD interest rates

- A re-peg is not de-peg

- USD rates remain anchor for HKD rates

- CNH increased chances of HKD repegging to CNY…
- … conditional on CNY becoming fully
convertible (~ 5 years’ time)
- Asset substitution – USD deposit base in
HK being eroded, not HKD deposit base
- Meanwhile, Hong Kong’ strong
fundamentals allow dollar peg

until HKD re-pegs
- Re-peg pressure will come from CNH
rates, not onshore CNY rates
- Fortunately, CNH rates are also anchored
by USD rates…
- … as long as China maintain border
control between CNH and onshore CNY
- Bigger uncertainty is in USD rates – when
will Fed starts hiking? when will it unwind
QE?

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

13

History of HKD dollar peg
USD/HKD forwards have not priced in resumption of CNY appreciation plus growth of CNH
7.95

8.4
8.2

7.90
8.0
7.85

7.8
7.6

7.80

7.4
7.75

7.2
7.0

7.70

6.8
7.65
6.6
7.60

6.4
99

00

USD/HKD spot

01
USD/HKD 1 yr

02

03
Upper CU

04
Lower CU

05

06

07

08

09

10

11

USD/CNY(RHS)

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

14

“Asset substitution” underway
CNH deposits are eroding USD deposits, not HKD deposits
4.5

100

HKD trn

% share

90

4.0

80

3.5

70
3.0
60
2.5
50
2.0
40
1.5
30
1.0

20

0.5

10

0.0

0
80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10
HKD

USD

CNY

Other fcy

80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10
HKD

USD

CNY

Other fcy

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

15

HKD FX forward vs. CNH forward – implying sustained HKD
depreciation vs. CNY
USD/HKD vs. CNH, onshore CNY, offshore CNY NDF
7.780

6.6

HKD/CNH vs. HKD/CNY, HKD/CNY NDF
0.845

7.775
6.6

7.770

0.840

7.765
0.835

6.5
7.760
7.755

0.830

6.5
7.750
7.745

6.4

0.825

7.740
6.4

7.735
O/N
CNH

1W 2W
1M
CNY onshore

2M 3M 6M
CNY NDF

9M
1Y
HKD (RHS)

0.820
O/N
HKDCNH

1W

2W
HKDCNY

1M

2M

3M

6M

9M

1Y

HKDCNY NDF

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

16

HKD interest rates vs. CNH rates – anomaly between interbank
deposit rates and implied swap offer rates
Interbank rates – hibor vs. CN-hibor, Libor

Rates implied from FX forward curves

1.4

1.0
0.5

1.2

0.0

1.0
-0.5

0.8
-1.0

0.6

-1.5
-2.0

0.4

-2.5

0.2
-3.0

0.0
O/N
CNH

1W

2W
USD

1M
HKD

2M

3M

6M

9M

1Y

-3.5
O/N
CNH

1M

2M

CNY onshore

3M

6M

CNY NDF

9M
HKD

1Y
USD Libor

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

17

HKD rates – front-end lower, curve to steepen vs USD
EFN vs. IRS

EFN vs. UST

7

7

6

6

5

5

4

4

3

3

2

2

1

1

0

0
02

03

EFN 2y

04

05

IRS 2y

06

07

EFN 10y

08

09

IRS 10y

10

11

02

03

EFN 2y

04

05

UST 2y

06

07

08

EFN 10y

09

10

11

UST 10y

Source: Bloomberg, RBS

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

18

The CNH Market

•
•
•
•

Types of CNH products
CNY, CNH and CNY NDF compared
CNH market liquidity
Examples of CNH FX investment products

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

19

Overview

• CNH market – developing and does not offer the liquidity many need to
hedge their risks
• Onshore CNY – generally not open to Hong Kong investors and
involves CNY/CNH basis risk
• CNY NDF/NDS – better liquidity than CNH but also involves basis risk
• Some structured investment products are available for participants
to reduce or increase exposure to CNH/HKD and/or provide better
yields than CNH money markets

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

20

Snapshot of CNH-denominated product availability

CNH product

Availability

Remarks

Spot

Yes

USD 500mn interbank volumes

Forward

Yes

There are now CNY DF, CNY NDF and CNH DF curves

CCS

Yes

Illiquid

Money market

Yes

Interbank trading relatively thin amid CNH ‘pooling’ in small
number of institutions

CDs/structured
notes

Yes for CDs

CDs launched; structured notes and deposits in early
development stage

FX options

Yes

Illiquid

Structured
products

Not all

Fully funded structures so far

Bonds

Yes

Hong Kong CNH bond market continues to build

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

21

CNH vs. onshore CNY and offshore CNY NDF
CNY

CNH

CNY NDF

China onshore

Abroad,
(Hong Kong for clearing)

Abroad

Who is allowed to
buy/sell

Only companies in China
(with supporting documents)

Everyone outside China

Everyone outside China

Freely convertible

No

Yes

n.a.

Products available

Spot, Forwards and Options

Spot, Forwards and Options

Forwards and Options

Remittance outside
China

No

n.a.

n.a.

Remittance into China

n.a.

Yes, for trade purposes

n.a.

Delivery

Delivery

Cash settled in USD

Current and capital account
with supporting documentation

Trade purposes into China
alone, otherwise restrictions

n.a.

No fixing

No fixing

2 business days ahead of
maturity

Trade documents, or
PBOC/SAFE approvals for
capital account transactions

Trade documents for
transfers into/out of China

None

Deep Spot and forward to 1y

Deep Spot and forward to 3
months, modest liquidity at
1 year

Location

How is it settled
Allowed purposes
Fixing

Documentation needed

Liquidity

NDF: Out to 1y
NDS: Liquid out to 5 years,
some liquidity out to 10
years

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

22

Market liquidity

Tenor

Daily Average
Volume

Volume per
Transaction

Bid to Offer

-

USD 10 bn

USD 10-15mm

10-20 pips

Liquid out to 1y -18
months

USD 6 bn

USD 10-15mm

50-100 pips

Onshore CNY Deliverable
USDCNY FX Spot
USDCNY FX Forwards &
Swaps

Offshore CNY Non Deliverable (settled in USD)
USDCNY Non Deliverable
Forward (NDF)

Up to 1y

USD 3-4 bn

USD 10-20mm

30-50 pips

USDCNY Non Deliverable
Cross Currency Swap
(NDS or NDCCS)

Liquid out to 5y

USD 20-50mm

USD 10-20mm

20-30 bppa

-

USD 400-500mm

USD 5mm

10-20 pips

USDCNH FX Forwards &
Swaps

Up to 1y

USD 250mm

USD 10mm

50-100 pips

Fixed Income Sovereign
Bonds

Up to 10y

Illiquid

CNH 5mm

50-100bp

Offshore CNH Deliverable
USDCNH FX Spot

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

23

USD dual currency investment linked to CNH
Indicative Terms & Conditions


USD Principal

: USD 10 million (equivalent to CNH Principal = CNH 65.2 million)



USD/CNH Spot Reference

: 6.5200



Tenor

: 3 Months



Strike

: 6.5200



Redemption Conditions
- if USD/CNH Spot at expiry is above Strike, Investor receives CNH Principal with 2.0% p.a. interest
- If USD/CNH Spot at expiry is at or below Strike, Investor receives USD Principal with 2.0% p.a. interest

Rationale and Benefits


This investment is suitable for investors who are sitting on idle USD cash and do not mind converting USD
into CNH.



Allows the investor to take advantage of the implied (from the FX market) and real (from the depo) CNH
yield difference as well as access to the CNH option market



This investment offers higher returns compared to the vanilla money market rates or the sell/buy USD/CNH
FX swap plus CNH deposit structure (USD 1.00% p.a.)

Risks


If there is depreciation on the Renminbi, the investor could be receiving less than his original invested
principal in USD terms.

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

24

CNY Credit Linked Note
Indicative Terms & Conditions


CNY Principal

: CNY 200 million, settled in Settlement Currency



Reference Obligation

: China Sovereign



Tenor

: 5 years



Coupon

: CNY 2.50% p.a. settled in Settlement Currency



Redemption

: 100% at maturity, or in event of default the recovery value after close-out of
hedges, settled in Settlement Currency



Settlement Currency
References

: USD or HKD (as mutually agreed on Trade Date) using onshore Spot

Rationale and Benefits


This investment is suitable for investors who are in need of CNY linked assets and who are comfortable with
China Sovereign credit risk



Different reference obligations can be used for a tailored risk/reward profile



This investment offers higher returns compared to the vanilla CNH money market rates and is available to
HK investors

Risks


Basis risk between CNH and CNY for investors hedging CNH liabilities



China Sovereign in addition to the usual issuer credit risk

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

25

Disclaimer
•This material has been prepared for information purposes only. The investments and investment services referred to herein are available only to persons to whom this
material may be lawfully delivered in accordance with applicable securities laws. This material is being distributed only to, and is directed only at, persons who have
professional experience in matters relating to investments, falling within Article 19(1) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 or to
other persons to whom this material may lawfully be communicated. This material is not available to retail customers within the meaning of the rules of the Financial
Services Authority (“FSA”). No securities (nor any related securities or other financial instruments or their related derivatives) (together “Securities") discussed herein may
be offered or sold in the United States (“US”) except pursuant to an exception from the registration requirements of the Securities Act of 1933. The material should not be
construed as an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or any interest in securities.
•The information contained herein is confidential and is intended for use only by the recipient (the “Recipient”). It should not be reproduced or disclosed to any other person
without the consent of The Royal Bank of Scotland plc. The material remains the property of The Royal Bank of Scotland plc and/or its affiliates (“RBS”) and must be
returned to RBS on request and any copies the Recipient has made must be destroyed.
•The information contained herein has been prepared by RBS on the basis of information provided by the issuer or one of more of its affiliates to assist interested parties in
making a preliminary analysis of this Private Placement transaction and does not purport to be all-inclusive or to contain all of the information that a prospective investor
may require to make a full analysis of the transaction.
•The terms of this presentation are qualified in their entirety by the Information Memorandum, which will be made available by RBS in respect of the transaction described
herein, which will supersede the terms hereof.
•This material is distributed on the express understanding that, whilst the information in it is believed to be reliable, it has not been independently verified by RBS. RBS
makes no representation or warranty (express or implied) of any nature, nor does RBS accept any responsibility or liability of any kind, with respect to the accuracy or
completeness of the information in this material. This shall not, however, restrict, exclude or limit any duty or liability to any person under any applicable laws or regulations
of any jurisdiction, which may not lawfully be disclaimed.
•The Recipient of this document should make its own independent evaluation of the transaction and of the relevance and adequacy of the information in this document and
should make such other investigations as it deems necessary to determine whether to participate in the transaction.
•RBS, and its connected companies, employees or clients may have an interest in the Securities mentioned in this material. This may involve activities such as dealing in,
holding, acting as market-makers, or performing financial or advisory services, in relation to any of the Securities referred to in this document. RBS may also have acted as
a manager or co-manager of a public offering of such Securities, and may also have an investment banking relationship with any of the companies mentioned in this
material.
•Any views or opinions (including statements or forecasts) constitute the judgement of RBS as of the date indicated and are subject to change without notice. RBS does not
undertake to update this document. The Recipient should not rely on any representation or undertaking inconsistent with the above paragraphs.
•Outside the United States, this material is issued by The Royal Bank of Scotland plc which is authorised and regulated in the United Kingdom by the FSA. In the United
States, this document is issued by RBS Securities Inc. a member of FINRA and an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of The Royal Bank of Scotland plc. RBS Securities Inc.
acts as agent for The Royal Bank of Scotland plc in connection with Securities activities in the United States.
•The Royal Bank of Scotland plc acts in certain jurisdictions as the authorised agent of ABN AMRO Bank N.V.
•The Royal Bank of Scotland plc. Registered in Scotland No. 90312. Registered Office: 36 St Andrew Square, Edinburgh EH2 2YB.
•The daisy device logo, RBS, The Royal Bank of Scotland and Make it happen are trade marks of The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc.

1st ASHK Investment & Risk Management Symposium

26



Source Exif Data:
File Type                       : PDF
File Type Extension             : pdf
MIME Type                       : application/pdf
PDF Version                     : 1.4
Linearized                      : No
Page Count                      : 26
Producer                        : GPL Ghostscript 8.15
Create Date                     : 2011:04:21 10:12:07
Modify Date                     : 2011:04:21 10:12:07
Title                           : Microsoft PowerPoint - 1. RBS (Final)
Creator                         : PScript5.dll Version 5.2.2
Author                          : User
EXIF Metadata provided by EXIF.tools

Navigation menu