March 12, 2007 04992F May 15 2014 Minutes
User Manual: 04992F
Open the PDF directly: View PDF 
.
Page Count: 34
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF
THE OHIO CIVIL RIGHTS COMMISSION
May 15, 2014
Lobby Hearing Room, Rhodes Office Tower
Columbus, Ohio
CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Hubert called the meeting to order at 9:30 a.m.
Commissioners Present:
Chairman Leonard Hubert
Commissioner Lori Barreras
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado
Commissioner Tom Roberts
Commissioner William W. Patmon, III
A quorum was present.
OCRC Staff Present:
G. Michael Payton, Executive Director; Keith McNeil, Regional Counsel/Director of Operations;
Stephanie Bostos Demers, Chief Legal Counsel; Desmon Martin, Director of Enforcement and
Compliance; Aman Mehra, Columbus Regional Director; Norman Gibson, Dayton Regional
Director; Darlene Newbern, Toledo Regional Director Vera Boggs, Cleveland/Akron Regional
Director; Ronnell Tomlinson, Director of Housing/Alternative Dispute Resolution; Courtney
Calhoun, Reconsideration Supervisor; Bradley Dunn, Reconsideration Supervisor; Lori
Anthony, Chief, Civil Rights Section – Ohio Attorney General’s Office; and Sandra Aukeman,
Administrative Assistant.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
MOTION by Commissioner Mercado to approve the April 24, 2014 minutes. Second by
Commissioner Roberts.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Tom Roberts YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras ABSTAIN
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 1 of 34
May 15, 2014
OCRC MINUTES Page 2 of 35
May 15, 2014
CONFIRMATION OF STAFF FINDINGS
1. Complainant’s Request for Reconsideration – Vacate Original No Probable Cause
Finding and Grant for Further Review
Anjomeda Taylor v. Ohio Health*
COL71(40302)06062013
22A-2013-02676C
*Commissioners Patmon and Barreras recused themselves from participation in this case
Lonnee E. Thomas v. Center of Vocational Alternatives for Mental Health, Inc.
COL71(40341)06202013
22A-2013-02807C
Jeffrey Ransom v. Owens-Brockway Glass Container, Inc.
COLA1(40346)06252013
22A-2013-02740C
Jeanine Wendy Molock v. State of Ohio, Department of Education*
COLA1(40348)06142013
22A-2013-02801C
*Commissioner Patmon recused himself from participation in this case
Jay Wollenburg v. Board of Education of the Ottawa Hills Local School District
TOLA2(36014)07012013
22A-2013-02604C
Lynn Downing v. Elaine Zajac
AKRH3(37024)07292013
05-13-1254-8
22A-2013-02927F
Nazih M. Darwiche v. Kent State University
CLEA3(37210)11252013
22A-2014-00504C
Robert J. Meyer v. State of Ohio, Department of Transportation
DAYA6(23722)07022013
22A-2013-03408C
Karen A. Mathis-Seiter v. Animal Care Center
DAYE6(23777)07292013
22A-2014-01070F
Tony Jackson v. The Board of Education of the Jackson City School District
DAY76(24078)12232013
22A-2014-00782C
2. Reconsideration by the Commission – Vacate Previous Issuance of Formal
Complaint
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Jerome Horton
AKRH4(42045)06242013 AMENDED
05-13-1060-8
22A-2013-02586F
3. Respondent’s Request for Reconsideration – Grant for Further Review
David and Sue Dunbar v. Linda and Richard Mussig
AKRH3(37046)08092013
05-13-1517-8
22A-2013-03029F
Fair Housing Advocates Association v. Linda and Richard Mussig
AKRH3(37047)08092013
05-13-1544-8
22A-2013-03028F
4. Withdrawal of Charge with Settlement; Dismiss Formal Complaint – Submitted by
the Attorney General’s Office
Harla Williams (nka Harla Allen) v. FHL Enterprises, LLC and Gary Lee
AKRH3(35831)06202011
05-11-1169-8
22A-2011-03279F
Complaint No. 11-HOU-AKR-35831
Stark County Fair Housing Department v. FHL Enterprises, LLC and Gary Lee
AKRH3(35832)06202011
05-11-1168-8
22A-2011-03280F
Complaint No. 11-HOU-AKR-35832
Fair Housing Advocates Association v. UMH OH Colonial Heights, LLC, and Terri
Prokorym, Community Manager
AKRH3(36605)10292012
05-13-1487-8
22A-2013-00389F
Complaint No. 13-HOU-AKR-36605
Brenda Mamula v. UMH OH Colonial Heights, LLC, and Terri Prokorym, Community
Manager
AKRH3(36606)10292012
05-13-1486-8
22A-2013-00390F
OCRC MINUTES Page 3 of 34
May 15, 2014
Complaint No. 13-HOU-AKR-36606
Withdrawal of Charge with Settlement; Dismiss Formal Complaint – Submitted by
the Attorney General’s Office - continued
Dale West v. Lawn Tech Inc.
CLE74(40919) 05122011
22A-2011-03213C
Complaint No. 11-EMP-CLE-40919
Valerie Cruz Figueroa v. Catholic Health Partners dba Mercy Regional Medical Center*
CLEB4(41715)09182012
22A-2012-03113C
Complaint No. 13-EMP-CLE-41715
*Commissioner Mercado recused herself from participation in this case
5. Independent Settlement; Dismiss Formal Complaint – Submitted by the Attorney
General’s Office
Dean Edward Arlington v. ANYI Apartments, LLC
COLH1(34539)11142006
22A-2008-00022F
Complaint No. 07-HOU-COL-34539
Naim Tiffany Wingo v. Alexander E. Grebelsky
COLH1(36316)01052009
05-09-0447-8
22A-2009-01610F
Complaint No. 09-HOU-COL-36316
Janine and Lemuel King v. Village of Holland, et al.
TOLH2(31035)01242007
22A-2007-02614F
05-07-0592-8
Complaint No. 07-HOU-TOL-31035
Trudy Vicary v. Village of Holland, et al.
TOLH2(31049)02022007
22A-2007-02810F
05-07-0606-8
Complaint No. 07-HOU-TOL-31049
Toledo Fair Housing Center v. Village of Holland, et al.
TOLH2(31050)02022007
22A-2007-02777F
05-07-0609-8
Complaint No. 07-HOU-TOL-31050
OCRC MINUTES Page 4 of 34
May 15, 2014
Independent Settlement; Dismiss Formal Complaint – Submitted by the Attorney
General’s Office – continued
Cheryl A. Smith v. Barbara Benschoter
TOLH2(33285)08042009
05-09-1670-8
22A-2009-03701F
Complaint No. 10-HOU-TOL-33285
Jennifer Hardwick v. Randall and Rebecca Schwilk
TOLH2(33921)06162010
22A-2010-03825F
Complaint No. 10-HOU-TOL-33921
Lisa Elliott v. Anthony Apostos
CLEH4(39749)07102009
22A-2009-03986F
Complaint No. 10-HOU-CLE-39749
Miami Valley Fair Housing Center, Inc. v. Gilbert Court at the Greene, et al.
DAYH6(19210)03162007
22A-2007-03454F
Complaint No. 08-HOU-DAY-19210
Nicole McDonald v. Arthur Burton
DAYH6(19325)05142007
22A-2007-04992F
Complaint No. 07-HOU-DAY-19325
Amy Rippel-Elton v. AandR Reck Sunset Terrace MHP, LTD
DAYH6(19382)06112007
05-07-1074-8
22A-2008-00191F
Complaint No. 07-HOU-DAY-19382
Alhassan Abdel-Rashid v. Thomas and Gloria Veskauf
DAYH6(19924)04072008
22A-2008-03531F
Complaint No. 09-HOU-DAY-19924
Miami Valley Fair Housing Center, Inc. v. Stone Crossing Apartments
DAYH6(20120)08202008
22A-2009-02803F
Complaint No. 09-HOU-DAY-20120
OCRC MINUTES Page 5 of 34
May 15, 2014
6. Issue Dismissal Order – Submitted by the Attorney General’s Office
Diana Labiche v. Greater Toledo Urban League
DAY72(32433)08112008
22A-2008-04552C
Complaint No. 09-EMP-DAY/TOL-32433
7. Common Pleas Court Election; Dismiss Formal Complaint – Submitted by the
Attorney General’s Office
Fair Housing Contact Service v. Liberty Street Apartments, et al.
AKRH3(35365)10082010
22A-2011-00902F
Complaint No. 11-HOU-AKR-35365
8. Probable Cause – Schedule Conciliation
Jewel R. Phillips v. Paul Tran and Associates, Inc. dba Espres Nails and Spa*
CLEB4(42155)08302013
22A-2013-03213C
*Split recommendation; Probable Cause finding on the issue of Hostile Work
Environment; No Probable Cause finding on the issue of Discharge
Brenda Smith v. Larry and Ruth Barnette
DAYH6(23821)08222013
05-13-1352-8
22A-2013-03162F
Miami Valley Fair Housing Center, Inc. v. Jack Conley and Emogene Conley
DAYH6(23855)09132013
05-13-1489-8
22A-2014-01110F
Algirdas Aukstuolis v. Matthew D. and Elizabeth A. Malone, Owners
DAYH6(24063)12102013
05-14-0235-8
22A-2014-00654F
9. Issue Formal Complaint
Fair Housing Contact Services, Inc. v. Robert Helming, Jr.
CLEH3(37001)07152013
05-13-1148-8
22A-2013-02693F
OCRC MINUTES Page 6 of 34
May 15, 2014
Issue Formal Complaint - continued
Chris A. Lee v. Aaron’s, Inc.
CLE74(42026)06102013
22A-2013-02394C
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Stephen D. Carver and Renate G. Carver
CLEH4(42047)06022013 AMENDED
05-13-1543-8
22A-2013-02565F
10. Ratify Conciliation Agreement after a Finding of Probable Cause
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Jerome Horton
AKRH4(42045)06242013 AMENDED
05-13-1060-8
22A-2013-02586F
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Edward C. Long and Mary A. Long
CLEH4(42044)06242013 AMENDED
05-13-1534-8
22A-2013-02563F
Rebel Stroman v. Pilot Travel Centers LLC (PTCLLC)
CLEG3(36968)06172013
22A-2013-02504F
11. Ratify Conciliation Agreement and Consent Order Prior to Final Determination –
Close
Christine Wilcox v. Harper Management Services, Inc. dba McDonald’s
COLB1(40408)07172013
22A-2013-03189C
Rebel Stroman v. Pilot Travel Centers LLC
AKRG3(37040)08062013
22A-2013-02943F
Fair Housing Contact Service, Inc. v. Donna Wolfe
AKRH3(37252)12232013 AMENDED
05-14-0726-8
22A-2014-00824F
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Cleveland Scene and CEGW, Inc.
AKRH4(42152)08232013 AMENDED
05-13-1306-8
OCRC MINUTES Page 7 of 34
May 15, 2014
22A-2013-03269F
Ratify Conciliation Agreement and Consent Order Prior to Final Determination –
Close - continued
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Jason Zaroslinski
AKRH4(42325)01222014 AMENDED
05-14-0412-8
22A-2014-00986F
Richard K. Bush v. Clerac, LLC dba Enterprise Rent-A-Car
ADR72(36272)11152013
22A-2014-00406C
Amanda Johnson et al v. Glenwood Estates Inc. et al; S-K Home Sales; S-K
Developments, Inc.; Stevie (LNU), Manager, Glenwood Estates Inc.
ADRH2(36469)03252014
05-14-0687-8
22A-2014-01649F
Lourie Ham fka Lourie M. Roosevelt v. Lutheran Homes Society, Inc.
ADRA2(36497)04102014
22A-2014-01659C
Willa Boyd v. Summit Management Services, Inc., Angelica Henley and Jewish Senior
Housing
ADRH3(37344)03072014
05-14-0655-8
22A-2014-01384F
Latoria Eason v. Lake Erie Prepatory School/I Can Schools
ADR74(42371)03032014
22A-2014-01341C
Eloise Harris v. AIY Properties, Inc./Audino Giovanni
ADRH4(42372)03052014
22A-2014-01357F
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Erik Campbell/Better Business Property, LLC
ADRH4(42392)03252014
22A-2014-01553F
Miami Valley Fair Housing Center, Inc. v. Timothy Baker, Baker Rental Property, and
Jens LLC
ADRH6(24206)03062014
22A-2014-01482F
OCRC MINUTES Page 8 of 34
May 15, 2014
12. Withdrawal of Charge with Settlement
Christine R. Drenner v. PADMNABH Inc. dba Quality Inn
TOL72(36009)07012013
22A-2013-02598C
Jessica L. Drenner v. PADMNABH Inc. dba Quality Inn
TOL72(36010)07012013
22A-2013-02599C
Rock Nissen v. State of Ohio, Department of Rehabilitation and Correction
TOL72(36041)07112013
22A-2013-02665C
Jennifer Murawski v. The TJX Companies, Inc. dba T.J. Maxx
TOLB2(36263)11132013
22A-2014-00387C
Kimberly Light v. Lutheran Homes Society, Inc. dba Lutheran Village at Wolf Creek
TOL72(36403)02242014
22A-2014-01206C
Tiara Williams v. Lutheran Homes Society, Inc. dba Lutheran Village at Wolf Creek
TOL72(36404)02242014 AMENDED
22A-2014-01207C
Steve Urbina v. Cintas Corporation
TOLA2(36439)03102014 AMENDED
22A-2014-01383C
James E. Dolan v. SAI Living, Inc.
AKRB3(37380)03282014
22A-2014-01549C
Charles and Gail Walker v. Federal National Mortgage Association
AKRH3(37383)04012014
05-14-0772-8
22A-2014-01607F
Charles Robinson v. Lake Metropolitan Housing Authority, Frank Bedenk, Christopher
Butler, Rick Ziemak and Mike Cody
AKRH4(42237)10242013
05-14-0038-8
22A-2014-00306F
Ledean L. Dungey v. Liberty Retirement Community
DAYB6(23756)07182013
22A-2013-03350C
OCRC MINUTES Page 9 of 34
May 15, 2014
Withdrawal of Charge with Settlement – continued
Eric Hill v. Keen Investment Inc. dba Olympic Garage
DAYE6(24142)02032014
22A-2014-01090F
Kevin Black v. UC Health dba University Hospital*
DAYB6(24143)02032014
22A-2014-01091C
*Commissioner Patmon recused himself from participation in this case
Kevin Black v. Aramark Healthcare Support Services Inc.
DAYB6(24144)02032014
22A-2014-01092C
Miesha Burton v. UC Health dba University Hospital*
DAY76(24153)02102014
22A-2014-01104C
*Commissioner Patmon recused himself from participation in this case
Miesha Burton v. Aramark Healthcare Support Services, LLC
DAY76(24154)02102014
22A-2014-01105C
Tamara Knisley v. Urbana Village North, Ltd, Wallick Properties Midwest, LLC; Valerie
Gano, Lisa Landis, Robert Daines
DAYH6(24184)02202014
05-14-0557-8
22A-2014-01312F
Tamara Knisley v. JAN, Ltd., dba Ronez Manor Apartments; Wallick Properties
Midwest, LLC; Judy Cairnes, Robert Daines, Jean Lameier
DAYH6(24185)02202014
05-14-0559-8
22A-2014-01313F
Eric Hill v. Keen Investment Inc. dba Olympic Garage
DAYE6(24251)04072014
22A-2014-01693F
Julie M. McDowell v. Wal-Mart Stores East LP
DAY71(40499)08222013
22A-2013-03364C
Sonja Burgess v. Guardian Care Services
ADRB1(40783)02072014
22A-2014-01295C
OCRC MINUTES Page 10 of 34
May 15, 2014
Withdrawal of Charge with Settlement – continued
Hilary Opara v. Crown Pointe Care Center
ADR71(40828)03052014
22A-2014-01578C
Nkechi Uma v. Crown Pointe Care Center
ADR71(40829)03052014
22A-2014-01534C
Katherine C. Dodd v. Window World Penn Ohio LLC dba Window World of
Youngstown
ADR73(37295)02052014
22A-2014-01035C
Janice L. Singer v. Anthraper Enterprises, Inc.
ADR73(37345)03072014
22A-2014-01385C
Alanna Klapp v. TerraSource Global Corporation
ADR73(37322)02202014
22A-2014-01189C
Nereste Gaston v. Artiflex Manufacturing, LLC
ADR74(42368)02272014
22A-2014-01301C
Kimberly Waite v. Dorchester Village, LLC
ADRH4(42326)01242014
05-14-0419-8
22A-2014-00987F
Gretchen M. Wittig v. Coffee Corners Antiques and Coffee House
ADRG4(42361)02242014
22A-2014-01247F
Chelsea Inman v. Ralph E. Wade Insurance Agency
ADRE6(24212)03112014
22A-2014-01485F
Youvona Clemens v. Robert Baird and Dayton Physicians, LLC
ADRB6(24226)03202014
22A-2014-01617C
OCRC MINUTES Page 11 of 34
May 15, 2014
13. Withdrawal of Charge – Grant
Sallie McCall v. Ohio Civil Service Employees Association, AFSCME Local 11, AFL-
CIO
COL71(40453)08022013
22A-2013-03091C
Reginald E. Wheeler v. State of Ohio, Department of Rehabilitation and Correction
COLA1(40728) 01092014
22A-2014-00921C
Luann M. Inman v. Dillard’s
TOLA2(36016)07022013
22A-2013-02610C
Dianna L. Salazar v. Block Communication, Inc. dba The Toledo Blade
TOLA2(36043)07122013
22A-2013-02683C
Mary B. Lauer v. Lucas County Court of Common Pleas
TOL72(36242)10302013
22A-2014-00287C
Kathryn Orlando-Rupert v. Pioneer Holdings, LLC dba Duds and Suds Laundry
TOLA2(36243)10302013
22A-2014-00289C
Andre M. Duff, Sr. v. Caravan Facilities Management L.L.C.
TOL72(36255)11052013
22A-2014-00335C
Kelly Jo Eddy v. Progressive C Stores, LLC dba Richmond Country Market
AKRB3(37090)09032013 AMENDED
22A-2013-03293C
Lyndsey Hughes v. City of Youngstown
AKR74(42285)12162013
22A-2014-00799C
Kathleen Dykin v. America’s Best Contacts and Eyeglasses
CLEG4(42418)04102014
22A-2014-01664F
Linda Carone v. Fairborn City Schools
DAYA6(23803)08122013
22A-2013-03150C
OCRC MINUTES Page 12 of 34
May 15, 2014
Withdrawal of Charge – Grant – continues
Oma Josephine Conway v. Progressive Quality Care, Inc. dba Schoenbrunn Healthcare
ADRA3(37361)03182014
22A-2014-01491C
14. Failure to Cooperate – Dismiss
Cedric Douglas v. Valley View Village
DAYH6(24241)03272014
22A-2014-01788F
15. Administrative Closure
Steaira Ballard v. Pathology Laboratories, Inc.
TOL72(36361)01272014
22A-2014-00989C
Lynette Dotson v. CareSource Management Group Co.
AKRB3(37140)10112013
22A-2014-00197C
Nina Kidd v. Carnegie Day Care Center, LLC
CLEE4(42291)12162013
22A-2014-00670F
16. No Probable Cause – Dismiss
Kristen J. Norington v. Funai Service Corporation
COL71(40322)06142013
22A-2013-02813C
Tamra J. Lowe v. City of Chillicothe
COL71(40328)06182013
22A-2013-02812C
Monica M. Adams v. State of Ohio, Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections
COLA1(40352)06192013
22A-2013-02796C
Aaron Cosby v. Scioto Services L.L.C.
COL71(40359)06282013
22A-2013-03008C
OCRC MINUTES Page 13 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Rochelle Estrada v. Chase Bankcard Services, Inc.
COLB1(40363)07022013
22A-2013-02750C
Carlos Henderson v. First Transit, Inc.
COLB1(40365)07032013
22A-2013-02752C
Takesha Dominique Green v. US Hair and Beauty, Inc., dba US Hair
COL71(40367)07032013
22A-2013-03004C
Lakeysha Jawara v. Pomegranate Health Systems of Central Ohio, Inc.
COL71(40374)07052013
22A-2013-02753C
Carlos Henderson v. First Transit, Inc.
COL71(40379)07092013
22A-2013-02733C
Victoria A. Mitchell v. State of Ohio, Rehabilitation and Corrections
COL71(40380)06242013
22A-2013-03242C
Sherry Gallion v. Provider Services, Inc. dba Countryview of Sunbury
COLA1(40387)07032013
22A-2013-03241C
Tara Leimeister v. AVI Foodsystems, Inc.
COL71(40394)07112013
22A-2013-03002C
Jeffrey Masser v. Abercrombie & Fitch Co.
COLA1(40398)07152013
22A-2013-03239C
Raj Wali Khan v. Mission Essential Personnel, LLC
COL71(40400)07082013
22A-2013-03237C
Tyeisha Lachele Heidelbiurg v. Bank of America
COL71(40401)07162013
22A-2013-03185C
Carlos Henderson v. First Transit, Inc.
COL71(40402)07162013
OCRC MINUTES Page 14 of 34
May 15, 2014
22A-2013-03186C
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Tracy Lynne Allen v. PetSmart
COL71(40403)07162013
22A-2013-03187C
Mikal Stanley v. IQOR Holdings US, Inc.
COL71(40407)0717013
22A-2013-03188C
Breanna Hughes v. Akzo Nobel Coatings, Inc.
COL71(40410)07172013
22A-2013-03190C
Erica C. Wilson v. Manor at Whitehall
COL71(40411)07182013
22A-2013-03245C
Galina N. Blanken v. Dublin Springs, LLC dba Dublin Springs Hospital
COLA1(40413)07192013
22A-2013-03244C
Linda C. Anderson v. Big Walnut Aerie Number 3261 Fraternal Order of Eagles
COLA1(40416)07232013
22A-2013-03227C
Rodney Langston for Jacob Langston v. Worthington Youth Boosters, Inc.
COLG1(40421)07242013
22A-2013-03311F
Charles Thomas v. Volt Management Corp.
COL71(40433)07302013
22A-2014-01508C
Sallie McCall v. State of Ohio, Department of Rehabilitation and Correction
COL71(40443)07262013
22A-2013-03079C
Rochelle Estrada v. Chase Bankcard Services, Inc.
COLB1(40452)08022013
22A-2013-03092C
Clement D. Evans v. Jude Holdings, LLC dba Fish Window Cleaning
COL71(40458)08062013
22A-2013-03309C
Eunice E. Jones v. HCA of Southern Ohio, LLC dba Home Care Assistance
COL71(40460)08062013
OCRC MINUTES Page 15 of 34
May 15, 2014
22A-2013-03310C
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Rochelle Estrada v. Chase Bankcard Services, Inc.
COLB1(40478)08142013
22A-2013-03058C
Ashraf Taherzadeh v. State Farm Insurance
COL71(40479)08142013
22A-2013-03060C
Simona Clardy v. Faith Mission, Inc.
COL71(40487)08192013
22A-2014-00018C
Paulette M. Pendleton v. JP Morgan Chase Bank, NA
COL71(40501)08262013
22A-2014-00296C
Tamra J. Lowe v. City of Chillicothe
COL71(40514)08282013
22A-2014-00259C
Nicholas P. Jacobs v. ManpowerGroup US Inc.
COL71(40551)09192013
22A-2014-00159C
Alice Gail Day v. Southwestern City Schools
COLB1(40554)09202013
22A-2014-00160C
Alisha Wright v. American Collection Systems, Inc
COL71(40559)09242013
22A-2014-00148C
Monique E. Davis v. Radke Investments LLC and Art Russo Realtors, LTD
COLH1(40569)09232013
05-13-1481-8
22A-2014-00300F
Venubabu Talasila v. REM Corporation
COL71(40587)10102013
22A-2014-00496C
Yvette S. Weaver v. State of Ohio, Department of Medicaid
COL71(40617)10252013
22A-2014-00575C
OCRC MINUTES Page 16 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Linda Anderson v. Big Walnut Aerie 3261 Fraternal Order of Eagles
COL71(40635)11062013
22A-2014-00547C
Robin J. McNerlin v. United Diary Farmers, Inc.
COL71(40657)11212013
22A-2014-00704C
Monique E. Davis v. Radke Investments LLC and Art Russo Realtors, LTD
COLH1(40665)11252013
22A-2014-00682F
Michael J. Smith v. Restoration Hardware, Inc.
COL71(40666)11262013
22A-2014-00692C
Michael J. Smith v. ProLogistix
COL71(40667)11262013
22A-2014-00691C
Elizabeth Jean Farthing v. Meijer Stores Limited Partnership
COLB1(40709)12182013
22A-2014-00925C
Yvette S. Weaver v. State of Ohio, Department of Medicaid
COL71(40713)12302013
22A-2014-01009C
Lillian Roberts on behalf of Joey Roberts v. Upper Arlington Schools
COLG1(40799)02112014
22A-2014-01420F
Jeffrey Lee Wyche v. Managed Labor Solutions
COL71(40888)03282014
22A-2014-01599C
Rebecca Taylor v. Primrose School at Pinnacle
COLB1(40889)03282014
22A-2014-01761C
Santos Rodriguez v. ProMedica Toledo Hospital
TOL72(36015)07012013
22A-2013-02605C
Peter M. Kahle v. Swan Creek Retirement Village
TOL72(36019)07032013
OCRC MINUTES Page 17 of 34
May 15, 2014
22A-2013-02615C
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Ingrid L. Brown v. City of Toledo
TOL72(36020)07032013
22A-2013-02616C
Jason Hall v. Terry L. Weaver, Owner
TOLH2(36026)07082013
05-13-1201-8
22A-2013-02633F
Kimberly Hairston v. Chrysler Group LLC
TOL72(36036)07102013
22A-2013-02657C
Daniel C. Lawniczak v. Universal Urethane Products, Inc.
TOL72(36037)07102013 AMENDED
22A-2013-02658C
Freddie M. Davis, Jr. v. Chrysler Group LLC
TOLB2(36038)07102013
22A-2013-02659C
Renell Butler v. Toledo Refining Company LLC
TOL72(36042)07122013
22A-2013-02681C
Lynell Gordon-Young v. Best Western Premier Grand Plaza Hotel dba Grand Plaza Hotel
TOLA2(36049)07162013
22A-2013-02728C
Nicole Pedelose v. FedEx Ground Package System, Inc.
TOLB2(36058)07232013
22A-2013-02778C
Karen Lincoln v. Board of Lucas County Commissioners, Lucas County Department of
Job and Family Services
TOLB2(36061)07232013
22A-2013-02795C
Terry Gullatt v. Mobis North America, LLC
TOLA2(36062)07242013
22A-2013-02855C
Willie Moore v. Chrysler Corporation
TOLA2(36070)07292013
22A-2013-02864C
OCRC MINUTES Page 18 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Tyra S. Garrett v. Mercy Integrated Laboratories
TOL72(36075)08012013 AMENDED
22A-2013-02880C
Isa A. Karim v. Mercy St. Anne Hospital
TOLG2(36085)08062013
22A-2013-02937F
Darla Turner-Karim v. Mercy St. Anne Hospital
TOLG2(36086)08062013
22A-2013-02938F
Mario Bongiorni v. General Motors LLC
TOL72(36091)08072013
22A-2013-02952C
Barbara Steck v. ProMedica Health System, Inc. dba ProMedica Toledo Hospital
TOLA2(36096)08082013
22A-2013-02977C
Jamall Hodges v. Land-O-Sun Dairies, LLC dba Frostbite Brands
TOLB2(36137)08292013
22A-2013-03200C
Pamela Smith v. Lucas Metropolitan Housing Authority
TOL72(36197)10032013
22A-2014-00052C
Juan Hall v. James E. Glen, Youngstown Community Housing COOP, Plaza
View, Inc., and Christine Cody
AKRH3(37067)08222013
05-13-1290-8
22A-2013-03147F
Chad Hardiman v. Time Warner Cable Enterprises, LLC
AKRB3(37115)09262013
22A-2013-03425C
Queen E. Flinn v. Penske Logistics LLC
AKRB3(37119)10012013
22A-2014-00027C
Tina Beal v. Communicare Family of Companies dba Pebble Creek Health Care Center
AKR73(37124)10032013
22A-2014-00033C
OCRC MINUTES Page 19 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Nicole Webb v. Blossom Nursing and Rehabilitation Centers, Inc.
AKR73(37136)10092013
22A-2014-00118C
Nicole Webb v. Essex Healthcare Corporation
AKR73(37137)10092013
22A-2014-00119C
Nicole Webb v. Atrium Living Centers, Inc.
AKR73(37138)10092013
22A-2014-00121C
Diamond T. Evans v. West View Manor, Inc. dba West View Healthy Living
AKRB3(37142)10152013
22A-2014-00201C
Deborah Parker v. Shaffer, Johnston, Lichtenwalter and Associates, Inc.
AKRH3(37205)11222013
22A-2014-00490F
Deborah S. Finch v. Compass Group USA, Inc.
AKRA3(37209)11252013
22A-2014-00503C
Patrice Nicole Borum v. Summa Health System dba Summa at Home
AKR73(37224)12052013
22A-2014-00597C
Ann Dunaway v. Crystal Clinic Orthopaedic Center, LLC
AKR73(37290)02032014
22A-2014-01031C
Juwana Owens v. Summit County Juvenile Court
AKR73(37313)02142014
22A-2014-01174C
Elaine Matthews v. K&D Management Co., Dorothy Rean, and Euclid-Richmond
Gardens, Ltd. dba Parkside Gardens Apartments
AKRH4(42132)08162013
05-13-1298-8
22A-2013-03097F
Linda Burke v. The Shelly Company
AKR74(42139)08202013
22A-2013-03120C
OCRC MINUTES Page 20 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Kanaiyalal and Anjana Patel
AKRH4(42148)08232013
05-13-1303-8
22A-2013-03218F
Paula Enlow v. Sorace Enterprises, Inc., Frank Sorace and Fred Colli, Agent, Fred Colli
AKRH4(42184)09192013
05-13-1506-8
22A-2013-03427F
Charlene M. Glass v. Friedman Properties, Ltd. dba Fox Run Apartments
AKRH4(42207)10082013
22A-2014-00089F
John Stiles, III v. FC Prime Investments LLC dba Tinkers Creek Apartments, McKinley
Inc. and Francesca McGhee, Property Manager
AKRH4(42217)10152013
05-14-0344-8
22A-2014-00209F
Charlene M. Glass v. Friedman properties, Ltd. dba Fox Run Apartments, Barb Bensi,
Leasing Agent, Angela Shepard and Michelle Crellin
AKRH4(42229)10222013
22A-2014-00272F
Geoffrey Mathews v. Natural Essentials, Inc.
AKR74(42318)01162014
22A-2014-00885C
Jewel R. Phillips v. Paul Tran and Associates, Inc. dba Espres Nails and Spa*
CLEB4(42155)08302013
22A-2013-03213C
*Split recommendation; Probable Cause finding on the issue of Hostile Work
Environment; No Probable Cause finding on the issue of Discharge
Phillip C. Jones v. Libra Industries, Inc.
CLEA4(42160)09062013
22A-2013-03333C
Lillie Gates-Austin v. City of Cleveland (Department of Public Safety)
CLE74(42167)09112013
22A-2014-00010C
Arlene Hawkins v. Wildcat, LLC
CLEA4(42333)02032014
22A-2014-01038C
OCRC MINUTES Page 21 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Augustina Sears v. Dolgencorp, LLC dba Dollar General
CLEG4(42356)02182014
22A-2014-01200F
Tracy M. Rupp v. The Arthur Corporation
CLEA4(42364)02262014
22A-2014-01297C
Jeffrey N. English v. Cuyahoga County Board of Elections
CLE74(42384)03192014
22A-2014-01455C
Sherrie J. Rye v. Autoneum North America, Inc.
CLEB2(36442)03142014
22A-2014-01396C
Allison R. Kidd v. Communicare Health Services, Inc. dba Copley Health Center
CLEA3(37008)07192013
22A-2013-02767C
Shauntae Metcalf v. Progressive Foam Technologies, Inc.
CLEB3(37058)08162013
22A-2013-03080C
Theresa Sitko v. Cardinal Health 200, LLC dba Cardinal Health
CLEA3(37069)08262013
22A-2013-03179C
Mellonie A. Cushion v. Eagleone Hot Shot, Inc.
CLE73(37073)08272013
22A-2013-03274C
Don Brenneman v. Myers Controlled Power
CLEB3(37074)08282013
22A-2013-03275C
John E. Buhalak v. The Village at St. Edward
CLEA3(37085)09032013
22A-2013-03288C
Gerald A. Buckingham, Sr. v. Wendy’s of Downtown, Inc.
CLEB6(40689)12092013
22A-2014-00676C
OCRC MINUTES Page 22 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Michael R. Woodworth v. Rockford Villa Apartments, et al.
DAYH6(23767)07242013
05-13-1329-8
22A-2013-03159F
Veeda Rucker v. ODRC-Warren Correctional Institution
DAYB6(23769)07252013
22A-2013-02914C
Andre Ross v. JTD Enterprises dba Penn Station
DAYB6(23775)07292013
22A-2013-02889C
Joyce Derriso v. Knock Back Nat's Club
DAYG6(23776)07292013
22A-2013-02920F
Stephanie M. Straughn v. Indian Springs Dental Excellence, Manju Kejriwal, DDS, Inc.
DAY76(23793)08072013
22A-2014-03146C
Tommy Jiles v. Premier Health Partners
DAY76(23820)08222013
22A-2014-00238C
Jeffrey Grim and Tara Grim v. Thomas Jamison and Ashlee Jamison
DAYH6(23825)08232013
05-13-1480-8
22A-2014-00229F
Karen Sanders v. Cincinnati Senior Care dba Hyde Park Health Center
DAYA6(23826)08262013
22A-2013-03462C
Thomas Williams v. State of Ohio, Department of Rehabilitation and Correction
DAY76(23830)08262013
22A-2013-03463C
Jeffrey Larkin v. The Kellogg Company
DAY76(23835)08302013
22A-2013-03367C
Larry Foster v. Gateway Shelter for Men; Joe Smith, Manager
DAYH6(23838)09032013
05-13-1516-8
22A-2013-03363F
OCRC MINUTES Page 23 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Caroline Beckelheimer v. Owner and/or Manager of 522 Grand Ave
DAYH6(23888)09262013
22A-2014-00753F
Melissa Ann Schmittauer v. Sam’s East, Inc.
DAY76(23901)10022013
22A-2014-00914C
Michael Adkins v. Sycamore Creek Apartments
DAYH6(23906)09302013
05-13-1509-8
22A-2014-01112F
Starlain Prater v. Indiana Wesleyan University
DAY76(24073)12172013
22A-2014-00673C
Bobby Coleman v. Formed Fiber Technologies Inc.
DAY 76(24074)12172013
22A-2014-00671C
Ruthgenia Trollinger v. Communicare of Clifton OHNH-EMP LLC
DAYA6(24098)01092014
22A-2014-00851C
LaKaira Canada v. Compass Group, USA, Inc. dba Morrison Healthcare
DAY76(24103)01132014
22A-2014-00896C
Laura Adams v. Reed Elsevier
DAYB6(24105)01142014
22A-2014-00901C
Kenneth Kemper v. Banfield Pet Hospital
DAYB6(24117)01212014
22A-2014-00962C
Marsha Shirley v. UC Health dba University Hospital*
DAYB6(24122)01232014
22A-2014-01027C
*Commissioner Patmon recused himself from participation in this case
Terry D. Bicknell v. Procter & Gamble
DAY76(24152)02072014
22A-2014-01059C
OCRC MINUTES Page 24 of 34
May 15, 2014
No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Suzanne Lau v. Sam's Club East, Inc.
DAYB6(24155)02102014
22A-2014-01218C
Paulina Cruz Reyes v. Carribean Arch Corp dba McDonald’s
DAY71(40427)07292013
22A-2013-03138C
Brandon Elkins v. Access Ohio Mental Health Center of Excellence
DAY71(40473)08132013
22A-2014-01624C
Michelle M. Hall v. Motel 6
DAY76(40498)08222013
22A-2014-01222C
Brandon Elkins v. Access Ohio Mental Health Center of Excellence
DAY71(40512)08292013
22A-2014-01111C
Fair Housing Advocates Association v. Evergreen Realty Inc., Ron Jeffries, Owner
DAYH1(40653)11202013
05-14-0297-8
22A-2014-00759F
James Rosier v. Evergreen Realty Inc., Ron Jeffries, Owner
DAYH1(40652)11202013
05-14-0296-8
22A-2014-00757F
MOTION by Commissioner Mercado to approve the May 15, 2014 Confirmation Agenda
with the noted recusals. Second by Commissioner Roberts.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Commissioner Roberts YES
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 25 of 34
May 15, 2014
STAFF BRIEFING
The Compliance Manager informed the Commissioners that the Commission is in compliance
with all notification requirements as set forth in Ohio Administrative Code Section 4112-1-04.
MOTION by Commissioner Mercado to approve the Compliance Department’s request to
delete the following cases from the Commissioner’s Agendas. Second by Commissioner
Roberts.
Week 3, Page 1, Item 3
Reverse Probable Cause to No Probable Cause – Insufficient Evidence to Meet Evidentiary
Burden; Dismiss Formal Complaint - ` Submitted by the Attorney General’s Office
Gloria J. Terry v. Arthur Recht
AKRH3(36558)09192012
22A-2012-03127F
The Charging Party’s representative is requesting an appearance before the Commissioners at an
upcoming Commission Meeting.
Week 1, Page 3, Item 3
No Jurisdiction – Dismiss
George McCauley v. Dove Tree Apartments;
Tim Barker, Manager; John (LNU)
DAYH6(24254)04082014
22A-2014-01721F
The Commission requests further review.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Commissioner Roberts YES
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 26 of 34
May 15, 2014
COMMISSIONER’S AGENDAS
Commissioner’s Agenda for Week 1
1. Requests for Reconsideration - Respondent’s Request – Deny
Jonathan A. Wicker and Natasha Holpp v. Ned G. Gibson,
Erin K. Cottrill, Jennifer L. Derwacter, and Marian D. Henthorne
COLH1(40623)10232013
05-14-0077-8
22A-2014-00421F
Housing Research and Advocacy Center v. Stephen D. Carver and
Renate G. Carver
CLEH4(42047)06242013
05-13-1543-8
22A-2013-02565F
2. Findings Upon Reconsideration – No Probable Cause – Dismiss
Jason Thornton v. City of Columbus, Department of Public Service
COL71(40290)05302013
22A-2013-02456C
Alvin Holloman v. Huntington National Bank*
COL71(40292)06032013
22A-2013-02805C
*Commissioners Patmon and Barreras recused themselves from participation in
this case
Dawn K. Watts v. Creative Foundations, Inc.
COLB1(40331)06102013
22A-2013-02808C
Roberta L. Jones v. City of Toledo, Affirmative Action Department
TOLB2(36407)02242014
22A-2014-01210C
Virginia Davis v. Warren Otologic Group, Inc. dba Libby Group
for Ear, Nose and Throat
AKRA3(36978)06212013
22A-2013-02534C
Pamela P. Moore v. Humana Pharmacy, Inc.
DAY76(23666)06122013
22A-2013-02996C
OCRC MINUTES Page 27 of 34
May 15, 2014
Commissioner’s Agenda for Week 1 – Page 2
Findings Upon Reconsideration – No Probable Cause – Dismiss – continued
Myra Shields v. Portsmouth City Schools
DAYA6(23676)06142013
22A-2013-02758C
MOTION by Commissioner Roberts to adopt the staff findings in the foregoing captioned
cases on the Week 1 Agenda with the above noted recusals. Second by Commissioner
Mercado.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Commissioner Tom Roberts YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 28 of 34
May 15, 2014
Commissioner’s Agenda for Week 2
1. Requests for Reconsideration - Respondent’s Request – Deny
David and Sue Dunbar v. Linda and Richard Mussig
AKRH3(37046)08092013
05-13-1517-8
22A-2013-03029F
Fair Housing Advocates Association v. Linda and Richard Mussig
AKRH3(37047)08092013
22A-2013-03028F
2. Findings Upon Reconsideration – No Probable Cause – Dismiss
Sharon Skidmore v. County of Summit, Board of Developmental Disabilities
CLE73(36990)07052013
22A-2013-02624C
Marchel Alsop v. Wright State University
DAYK6(23656)06052013
22A-2013-02785F
Andrea Wilson v. Evergreen Southwest Behavioral Health
Services dba Bridgewell Hospital
DAY76(23705)06252013
22A-2013-02716C
3. No Jurisdiction – Dismiss
Sue Lykes v. CSL Plasma Inc.
AKRG3(37412)04212014
22A-2014-01880F
Donna R. Shepherd v. Stark State College
AKRG3(37426)04292014
22A-2014-01865F
James C. Stanton v. Stark State College
AKRG3(37427)04292014
22A-2014-01866F
OCRC MINUTES Page 29 of 34
May 15, 2014
MOTION by Commissioner Mercado to adopt the staff findings in the foregoing captioned
cases on the Week 2 Agenda. Second by Commissioner Roberts.
Roll Call vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Tom Roberts YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 30 of 34
May 15, 2014
Commissioner’s Agenda for Week 3
1. Findings Upon Reconsideration - No Probable Cause – Dismiss
Anjomeda Taylor v. Ohio Health*
COL71(40302)06062013
22A-2013-02676C
*Commissioners Patmon and Barreras recused themselves from participation in
this case
2. No Jurisdiction – Dismiss
Joe Lariosa v. State of Ohio, Rehabilitation Services Commission
COLG1(40710)12232013
22A-2014-00928F
MOTION by Commissioner Roberts to adopt the staff finding in the foregoing captioned
cases on the Week 3 Agenda with the above noted recusals. Second by Commissioner
Mercado.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Tom Roberts YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 31 of 34
May 15, 2014
Commissioner’s Add – On Agenda
Upon Remand: Consideration of the Administrative Law Judge’s Amended Report and
Recommendation
Raven Black-Halicki v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters,
Local 377
AKR73(32552)06192007
22A-2007-05312C
Complaint No. 08-EMP-AKR-32552
MOTION by Commissioner Mercado to accept the Administrative Law Judge’s amended
report and adopt her recommendation in the foregoing captioned case on the Add – On
Agenda. Second by Commissioner Roberts.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Tom Roberts YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Motion carried.
OCRC MINUTES Page 32 of 34
May 15, 2014
CHAIRMAN HUBERT’S REPORT
Chairman Hubert announced we have received an invitation from Dennison University in
Granville, Ohio to hold our regularly scheduled October 23, 2014 Commission Meeting on their
campus.
MOTION by Commissioner Patmon to hold our regularly scheduled October 23, 2014
Commission Meeting at Dennison University in Granville, Ohio. Second by Commissioner
Roberts.
Roll Call Vote:
Chairman Leonard Hubert YES
Commissioner Tom Roberts YES
Commissioner Stephanie Mercado YES
Commissioner William Patmon YES
Commissioner Lori Barreras YES
Motion carried.
CHIEF LEGAL COUNSEL’S REPORT
Stephanie Bostos Demers, Chief Legal Counsel updated Commissioners on House Bill 333, as
amended.
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT
Director Payton reminded all those who must file an annual report with the Ohio Ethics
Commission that the deadline is today.
Our annual statewide staff training will be at Blacklick Metro Park on August 28, 2014. Our
Commissioners are invited to attend the event.
Chief Legal Counsel, Stephanie Bostos Demers, recently met with the Ohio State Bar
Association.
OCRC MINUTES Page 33 of 34
May 15, 2014
