1343033037DFMIssue11 Article1

1343043953Dfmissue11 Article 1343043953DFMIssue11_Article 1343043953DFMIssue11_Article 09 2014 uploads wp-content wordpress edecdf-wp-bucket

1343033037Dfmissue11 Article 1343033037DFMIssue11_Article 1343033037DFMIssue11_Article 09 2014 uploads wp-content wordpress edecdf-wp-bucket

1343032753Dfmissue11 Article 1343032753DFMIssue11_Article 1343032753DFMIssue11_Article 09 2014 uploads wp-content wordpress edecdf-wp-bucket

1343043953Dfmissue11 Article1 1343043953DFMIssue11_Article1 1343043953DFMIssue11_Article1 09 2014 uploads wp-content wordpress edecdf-wp-bucket

2015-04-17

: Edec 1343033037Dfmissue11 Article1 1343033037DFMIssue11_Article1 09 2014 uploads wp-content wordpress

Open the PDF directly: View PDF PDF.
Page Count: 7

Download1343033037DFMIssue11 Article1
Open PDF In BrowserView PDF
The Quarterly Magazine for Digital Forensics Practitioners

WI
N!

A
CE TA
LL RA
PH NT
ON UL
EA AC
NA HIN
LY ES
SI
S E
KI
T

ISSUE 11

MAY 2012

DATA THEFT

Jim Grier explains how to carry out an investigation, when
no artefacts exist, using his stochastic forensics approach
/ REGULARS
robservations, 360,
news, irq & more…
DF11_OFC_Cover - Online.indd 1

/ FROM THE LAB
Image Metadata for
Effective Data Mining

/ INTRODUCING
Cyber Warfare &
Covert Channels

02

9 772042 061127
Issue 11 / £14.99

TR Media

/ Book Reviews
INCLUDING The Basics
of Digital Forensics
25/04/2012 14:05

/ FEATURE

CHINESE CELL PHONES
& DIGITAL FORENSICS
In this article, we explain why investigators need to understand the macro trends in
the cell phone industry driving the incorporation of more Chinese chipsets in phones
and the challenges that they present to examiners. We also lift the lid on Tarantula,
a new analysis system developed to analyze problematic Chinese “white box” cell
phones and, increasingly, the legitimate branded phones based on Chinese chipsets.
by Kevin J North
/ INTERMEDIATE
Hercules had to defeat a hydra as one of his 12 labours.
It was a monster with 9 heads, and if Hercules smashed
one head, two more would take its place. For mobile
forensic investigators, Hercules’ hydra takes the form of
Chinese cell phones. More specifically, knock-off phones,
known internationally as “white-box” or “clone-phones”
and “Shanzhai” (pirated goods) in China, have taken world
markets by storm. In 2011, over 800 million cellular mobile
devices in close to 40,000 models were manufactured in
China. Approximately half of those were exported to world
markets, comprising of more than 30% of the global cell
phone market.

40

DF11_40-43_Chinese Cell Phones.indd 40

/ Simple Beginnings
Chinese cell phones came into existence as a result of China’s
unparalleled manufacturing base fuelled by abundant, lowcost labour, a flood of international investment, a robust
supply chain, and the world’s largest market. In southern
China, manufacturing plants dominate the landscape and the
city of Shenzhen is the epicentre of the cell phone industry.
More specifically, Shenzhen’s North Huangqiang Street is
China’s major hub for mobile phone commerce.
In the early 2000s, a Taiwanese integrated circuit (IC)
manufacturer, MediaTek launched an innovative business

Digital / ForensicS

25/04/2012 14:31

strategy in China, offering hardware packages called “systems
on a chip” (SoC) for wireless communication devices. This
development opened the door for small, entrepreneurial
teams with as few as 4 people to design and contract
manufacture, cell phones.
Entrepreneurs, both legitimate and illegitimate,
leveraged these hardware packages and the manufacturing
environment to rapidly produce even relatively small runs
of phone designs. Hundreds of small companies known as
independent design houses (IDH) in Shenzhen alone churn
out white box phones with a dazzling array of features; many
useful, some highly creative, and others entirely fake. The
fastest producers can get from idea to market in less than 30
days compared to months or years for larger international
cell phone companies. With near unlimited demand
domestically and a foreign market hungry to participate
in the digital revolution but often unable to buy expensive
branded phones; China has become a world leader in mobile
phone production, rivalling even their more established
western counterparts.
While not produced with quality in mind, white box
technology is attaining a level of complexity that is nearly state
of the art. Knock off makers follow industry trends to take
advantage of the accomplishments of legitimate technology
developers. White-box devices have advanced rapidly from
simple feature phones to include the same high end features on
popular international brands, and now smart phones.
High-end clones can be visually nearly indistinguishable
from the legitimate phones that they mimic, including popular
iPhone and Blackberry handset models. In many cases the
knock-offs use components from the same sub-suppliers as the

legitimate manufacturer. White box phones
often adopt famous brands that have nothing
to do with the cell phone industry like Adidas or
Marlboro and manufacturers are opportunistic,
building a phone around available parts until they run out;
then moving on to the next opportunity. The transient and
shadowy nature of the industry frustrates any standardization
for hardware or software found in these phones.
While IDH’s customize the phones they develop, the
core features such as screen resolution, Bluetooth, media
capability or network support are determined by the
specifications of the SoC (chipset) they decide to use.
For roughly ten years, the hardware packages from the
top Chinese chipset manufactures were closed platform,
offering only feature phone capability. In mid 2011,
however, a major shift occurred with the introduction of
Chinese chipsets supporting Android. The driving force
of white box innovation is really at the hands of the SoC
manufacturers, and they are meeting market demands with
cutting-edge chip sets able to run smart phone operating
systems, albeit at a higher price than the ultra low cost
feature phones that still flood the market.

CHINA HAS BECOME A WORLD
LEADER IN MOBILE PHONE
PRODUCTION, RIVALLING EVEN
THEIR MORE ESTABLISHED
WESTERN COUNTERPARTS

41

DF11_40-43_Chinese Cell Phones.indd 41

25/04/2012 13:38

/ FEATURE

In some cases, white box phone manufacturers like
Tianyu or Oppo have become so sophisticated and so well
established as producers that they eventually “go legit” with
their own brands. More mainstream brands like HuaWei, ZTE,
TCL and Lenovo are some of the largest brands using the
Chinese chipsets in their phones, selling their phones through
China’s three largest carriers.

/ Barriers to Analysis
The non-standard nature of Chinese phones makes them vexing
to mobile forensics examiners. They are often built on unique
or modified operating systems with modifications that may
only exist in a certain production run of a handset model. Until
recently all white box phones were embedded platforms, not
open source, and many contain distinct file system structures.
Another hindrance to forensic analysis is the absence of
standards for hardware such as data cables. Even though the
cables that come with these phones may look the same as the
cables that come with Android or iPhone handsets, the wiring
is often different. This is sometimes a deliberate strategy by
manufacturers to maximize accessory sales. Unfortunately
it also impedes the task of the digital forensics investigator,
as it can be difficult to establish compatibility between these
phones and forensic analysis tools.
While standard logical cell phone tools use synchronization
to extract data, white box manufacturers typically block
synchronization features. Even when the hardware
is compatible, phone manufacturers may disallow
synchronization through the software as a means of
simplifying the devices. (The transfer of media files is typically
supported however).
The barriers to analysis of white box phones come down
to one core issue, the absence of industry standards.
Unfortunately, hundreds of millions of cell phones are
circulating in worldwide markets that are so cheap they are
nearly disposable, that accommodate multiple SIM chips,
function across national borders, and are inherently difficult to
analyze, making them perfect for criminal activity and a huge
challenge for investigators.

/ A Global Issue
Further compounding the threat, these phones are quickly
internationalized, moving from China to Southeast Asia, the
Middle East, Africa and beyond. They may be flashed and
re-flashed with new software, exacerbating the problem of
tracking the devices with issues like non-unique IMEI numbers
and IMEI numbers that do not relate to manufacturing origin
or phone model. Certain countries like the United Kingdom
prohibit by law the changing of IMEI numbers, a practice that
is commonplace with white box phones.
If you think the adoption of smart phones will make the
Chinese phone problem go away, think again. Market research
firm, Strategy Analytics, reports that while the US is still the
largest smartphone market overall, China overtook the US
as the largest market for smartphones retailing below $ 170
(the fastest growing segment of the market). Major Chinese
chipset manufacturers; MediaTek, Infineon, Spreadtrum, and
42

DF11_40-43_Chinese Cell Phones.indd 42

/ Inside the Chinese Chip Market
Approximately 800 million Chinese chipped cell phones
entered the global market in 2011, making up nearly 35% of
devices worldwide. Given the rapid increase in prevalence,
popularity and sophistication of these devices, it is important
to know who makes the chipsets that allow them to operate.
As the industry leaders, the companies below will shape the
future of white-box mobile devices.
Top White-box Chip Makers:
• MediaTek (MTK): (Approximate Market Share 60%)
MediaTek develops chips for everything from GPS systems to
HDTVs. MediaTek is the world’s second largest producer of
semiconductors to the cell phone industry, after Qualcomm.
• Spreadtrum: (Approximate Market Share 30%) As the second
largest white-box chipset manufacturer, Spreadtrum has its
sights set on MediaTek and has doubled its market share
over the past decade.
• Infineon Technologies: (Approximate Market Share 5%) A
spin-off of Siemens AG in 1999, Infineon made its name by
providing semiconductors to the automotive, industrial and
multimarket sectors before entering the cell phone industry.
• M-star Semi Conductor: (Approximate Market Share 5%)
Split from System General Technology in 2002, MStar
specializes in mixed-mode integrated circuit technologies.
MStar is known in China as “Little-M”, contrasting the firm
with “Big-M” – MediaTek.

Mstar are racing to develop chipsets to serve this market
and Chinese phone manufacturers like Huawei, ZTE, TCL, and
Lenovo are designing smart phones. Even non-Chinese brands
like Motorola and Alcatel are incorporating Chinese chipsets in
some of their less expensive smartphones and in India, Spice
Mobile and Micromax are designing smart phones around lowcost Chinese chipsets. Strategy Analytics predicts that the sales
of lower cost smart phones will triple from 191 million phones
in 2012 to 551 million phones in 2016, with 75% being exported
to emerging markets. So whether they are in feature phones or
smart phones, Chinese chip based phones are here to stay.

/ It’s Not About Phones; Its About Chipsets
Fortunately, even in the face of all these hindrances to
analysis, there is a light at the end of the tunnel for mobile
forensic professionals. Even with tens of thousands of handset
models on the market, over 90% of the chipsets at the heart
of these devices are designed and built primarily by four
firms: Spreadtrum, Infineon, MStar and MediaTek (MTK). The
concentration of manufacturers enables forensics technology
Digital / ForensicS

25/04/2012 13:38

analyze data and evidence from them. Integrating Tarantula
with Logicube’s data extraction device, CellXtract, provides
added functionality that will give law enforcement, military
and government agencies an unparalleled solution to address
the thousands and thousands of phones, including legitimate
brands and white box, manufactured with Chinese chipsets.”

/ Looking Forward

developers to focus their efforts on tools that can physically
analyze the chipsets on which the phones are designed.
International mobile forensic companies are working on
technologies to address the growing problem of phones based
on Chinese chipsets. At the forefront of this effort is EDEC
Digital Forensics with Tarantula, currently the only forensic
tool that can extract and decode data from all 4 major Chinese
chipset manufacturers (comprising about 90% of all phones
that include Chinese chipsets), In addition to decoding data
such as phone book contacts, call logs, and SMS messages,
Tarantula acquires deleted data, PIN lock codes and IMEIs
(both current and historical, if present) from most chipsets.
In demonstrations to the state police forces in Australia,
Jason Hanel, Owner of Task Intelligence, a security and
investigation firm located near Canberra, Australia, invited
them to bring their own Chinese phones. In all cases, Tarantula
has succeeded in getting data. Phones purchased whilst in
Singapore and Indonesia were also tested with good results.
In addition, Cellebrite’s UFED CHINEX is a connectivity kit for its
UFED Physical Analyzer. Chinex is capable of physical extraction
of critical data from a subset of phones based on MediaTek
chips. Micro Systemation’s XRY system is capable of logical data
extraction from a subset of several hundred Chinese phones.
Oxygen Forensics recently updated their proprietary Oxygen
Forensic Suite 2012 to support MediaTek phones and Logicube
has announced that it has a licensing agreement with EDEC
allowing it to integrate Tarantula into its own CellXtract product
allowing it to do physical analysis on Chinese phones.

/ Industry Cooperation
While there may be competition between the leading
developers of digital forensics tools, there is also a good deal
of cooperation and collaboration. As much as executives want
their products to outsell the competition, they recognize the
need to provide effective tools to as many law enforcement as
possible. This was evidenced in March of this year, eDEC and
Logicube announced that they were partnering to combine
Tarantula software with CellXtract hardware. The finished
product is slated to debut at this year’s Techno Security &
Digital Investigations and Mobile Forensics Conferences in
Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, USA.
In a release regarding the partnership, Logicube Executive
Vice President and COO Farid Emrani stated, “Our digital
forensics customers are encountering large quantities of these
types of phones, creating an urgent requirement to extract and

There is no doubt that cell phones based on Chinese chipsets
will continue to present a challenge to investigators for the
foreseeable future. MediaTek, Spreadtrum and other IC
manufacturers are not only vying for position in the Chinese
market, they are also making headway in the global market by
signing deals with the world’s top cell phone manufacturers.
Feature phone chipsets that have been utilized by Chinese
IDHs for years, such as Mediatek’s MT6226 or MT6253 are
showing up in low cost handsets from international firms like
Motorola and Alcatel.
With the core strength of cell phone hardware
manufacturing achieved, Chinese chipset manufacturers are
now expanding their reach to include a wider range of mobile
device types. MediaTek’s smartphone chipset, MT6573, and
Spreadtrum’s SC8810 are capable of supporting Android
tablets, a device category previously dominated by Western
IC firms. Both companies are working to create chipsets that
support Japanese and Korean networks, another category
previously served by international players. The landscape of
mobile devices is shifting as Chinese chipsets manufacturers
evolve at unprecedented speed.
To be prepared for all potential scenarios, forensics
investigators need to ensure that they are trained in the
latest acquisition methods for the latest devices. By the same
token, forensics tool developers will need to remain vigilant
and cooperate with one another to remain at the forefront of
Chinese chip technology.
While there are many factors that make analysis of Chinese
built devices exceedingly difficult, the silver lining is that there
is a whole industry rising to these challenges. The best way
forensic investigators can prepare for the future is to pay careful
attention to industry trends and seek out the appropriate
educational programs to ensure that they are as well versed in
this emerging field. The bottom line is that Chinese technology
is here to stay, so we might as well adapt to it. /

/ Author Bio
Kevin J. North is an American freelance
journalist who specializes in the fields of
finance and technology. He is a graduate of
Monmouth University in West Long Branch,
New Jersey, with a Bachelors Degree in
Public Relations and Journalism. Currently,
Mr. North resides in Santa Barbara,
California, where he writes and edits articles related to digital
forensics, automotive safety technology and financial advice
for investors. In addition to his work as a journalist, Mr. North
serves as a consultant to the health and wellness, web design,
entertainment, and data acquisition industries.

43

DF11_40-43_Chinese Cell Phones.indd 43

25/04/2012 13:38

COMPETITION
/ This issue we have A TARANTULA CHINESE CELL PHONE
ANALYSIS KIT TO GIVE AWAY, COURTESY OF EDEC

/ Question

In his article, “Visualising Photographic Image Metadata for
Effective Data Mining”, Ollie Whitehouse explains that image
metadata can be stored in three formats, EXIF, IIM and XMP.
What does the acronym XMP stand for?

A. EXTENSIBLE METADATA PLATFORM
B. EXTENDABLE METADATA PLATFORM
C. EXTENDABLE METADATA PROCESSES

/ To Enter

To enter the competition all you need to do is send an
email to: competition@digitalforensicsmagazine.com,
writing ISSUE11COMP in the subject line, include your
name address and phone number with your entry.

TERMS AND CONDITIONS
This competition is open to anyone aged 18 or over, except for
employees of TR Media Ltd and their immediate families. Only
one entry is permitted per person. Entries can be submitted
by email only to competition@digitalforensicsmagazine.
com. TR Media shall not be responsible for technical errors in
telecommunication networks, Internet access or otherwise,
preventing entry to this competition. Closing date for all entries
is on 1 June 2012 at 9.30am GMT. Any entries received after that
time will not be included. The correct winning entry,
chosen at random by the DFM team, will be notified by email on
01/07/2012. The winners may also be announced in Issue 11 of
the magazine and on the Digital Forensics Magazine website.
Submitting your entry constitutes your consent for us to use
your name for editorial or publicity purposes, should you be
one of the winners. TR Media Ltd reserves the right to change or
withdraw the competition and/or prize at any time. By entering
the competition, entrants are deemed to have accepted these
terms and conditions.

56

DF11_56_Competition.indd 56

26/04/2012 10:05

DF11_44_Ad.indd 44

22/04/2012 13:32



Source Exif Data:
File Type                       : PDF
File Type Extension             : pdf
MIME Type                       : application/pdf
PDF Version                     : 1.6
Linearized                      : Yes
XMP Toolkit                     : Adobe XMP Core 4.0-c321 44.398116, Tue Aug 04 2009 14:24:30
Modify Date                     : 2012:06:29 10:46:55-07:00
Create Date                     : 2012:06:29 10:43:54-07:00
Metadata Date                   : 2012:06:29 10:46:55-07:00
Creator Tool                    : Adobe InDesign CS5 (7.0)
Format                          : application/pdf
Document ID                     : uuid:4fb3e8f7-8cc3-c54e-ad4d-2cd205f86882
Instance ID                     : uuid:1bbad85d-995c-5543-be62-f94c14431011
Producer                        : Mac OS X 10.5.8 Quartz PDFContext
Page Count                      : 7
Creator                         : Adobe InDesign CS5 (7.0)
EXIF Metadata provided by EXIF.tools

Navigation menu