MergedFile 3981846f Dee5 420a 8934 De1f9256c421

2018-06-13

: Pdf 3981846F-Dee5-420A-8934-De1F9256C421 3981846f-dee5-420a-8934-de1f9256c421 6 2018 pdf

Open the PDF directly: View PDF PDF.
Page Count: 40

DownloadMergedFile  3981846f-dee5-420a-8934-de1f9256c421
Open PDF In BrowserView PDF
6/12/2018

Global Neurosurgery:
Building Neurosurgery, Training, and
Research

Michael M. Haglund MD, PhD, MACM, FAANS, FCS (ECSA)
Distinguished Professor of Neurosurgery, Neurobiology, and Global Health
Division Chief, Duke Global Neurosurgery and Neurology
Program Director, Duke Neurosurgery Training Program
Program Director Uganda East African Neurosurgery Training Program
Chief External Examiner, Fellowship in Neurosurgery COSECSA

Duke Division of Global
Neurosurgery and Neurology

Disclosures: Nuvasive for DGNN Grant Funding for East
Africa, UCB Pharmaceuticals for Epilepsy Centers of
Excellence

World Population

Worldmapper.org

1

6/12/2018

World Physicians
US: 3,600 Neurosurgeons

Africa: 565 Neurosurgeons

African Regions
Northern
Eastern
Southern
Central
Western

Neurosurgery in Africa 2007
Countries in
East Africa

Total
Population

No. of
Neurosurgeons

Ration
Neurosurgeons
to population

Neurosurgical
Centers

Neurosurgery
Training
Program(s)

Northern
Africa and
South Africa:
486 of 563
NSUs

Morocco

32 million

171

1:187,000

15

6

Uganda

30 million

5

1:6 million

2

0

East Africa

270
million
320
million

27

1:10 million

13

5

3,600

1:88,000

17 in NC

95

United States

2

6/12/2018

Duke Neurosurgery
East Africa Project
Problems: 2007
1)
2)
3)
4)

Only 1 Neurosurgeon for 6 million people in Uganda
No technology (one ventilator in 1,500 bed hospital)
No operating room dedicated to Neurosurgery
No Neurosurgery training program to train more
neurosurgeons

Solutions: 4-Ts

1) Technology: Duke Global Health PLUS (Placement of Life-giving
Useable Surplus): Dr. Dzau, Dr. Merson, Jane Pleasants

2) Twinning: Teams of 23-55 medical professionals (1-2 trips/year)
3) Training: Neurosurgery Training Program in Uganda (FIENS)
4) Top Down Approach: All specialties and their patients benefit

Duke Twinning: One on One Training

2007- 2017: 438 Volunteers on 16 trips
31,600 hours, $2.1 million in donated time
417 surgeries

Duke Technology Transfer:
– Total Ten Years:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

2007:
$1,275, 000/ 9 tons equipment/supplies & $90,000 donations
2008:
$1,875,000/ 8 tons equipment/supplies & $150,000 donations
2009:
$ 750,000 / 4 tons equipment/supplies & $140,000 donations
2010:
$ 1,3750,000/ 7 tons equipment/supplies & $135,000 donations
2012 (2): $ 875,000/ 8 tons equipment/supplies & $175,000 donations
2013 (2): $ 850,000/ 10 tons equipment/supplies & $240,000 donations
2014 (2): $1,125,000,000/ 11 tons equipment/supplies & $200,000 donations
2015 (2): $1,005,000/13 tons equipment/supplies & $375,000 donations
2016 (2): $ 950,000/12 tons equipment/supplies & $500,000 donations
2017 (2): $ 1,050,000/11 tons equipment/supplies & $275,000 donations
Total: 44,118,536,000 UGX and 11,880,000,000 UGX in donations
Total: $12,255,000 and 93 tons of equipment & supplies,
$3,300,000 donations to develop three Neurosurgery Hospitals

– Benefactors:
–
–
–
–
–
–

Duke University Health System: Former Chancellor Victor Dzau, Jane Pleasants,
Chancellor Eugene Washington
Duke University: President Richard Brodhead
Duke Global Health Institute: Director Michael Merson
Division of Neurosurgery: Dr. Allan Friedman, Dr. John Sampson
Corporate Support: Nuvasive, Synthes Spine, Integra Neuroscience, Biomet, K2M

3

Cases (n)

FY
09

FY
09

FY
09

FY
09

FY
08

FY
08

qt
r4

qt
r3

qt
r2

qt
r1

qt
r4

qt
r3

qt
r2

FY
09

FY
09

FY
09

FY
09

FY
08

FY
08

FY
08

qt
r4

qt
r3

qt
r2

qt
r1

qt
r4

qt
r3

qt
r2

qt
r1

Initiation Duke NSU Program

30

FY
08

qt
r4

qt
r3

qt
r2

qt
r1

qt
r4

qt
r3

Cases (n)
40

FY
08

FY
07

FY
07

FY
07

FY
07

FY
06

qt
r2

qt
r1

50

qt
r1

qt
r4

qt
r3

qt
r2

qt
r1

qt
r4

FY
06

FY
06

FY
06

Elective OR + Duke NSU Camp
NSU Elective OR

FY
08

FY
07

FY
07

FY
07

FY
07

FY
06

qt
r3

Cases (n)
60

qt
r2

qt
r1

60

FY
06

FY
06

FY
06

6/12/2018

Neurosurgical Cases per Qtr

70

20

10

0

Neurosurgical Cases per Qtr

70

Elective OR + Duke NSU Camp
NSU Elective OR

50

40

30

20

10

0

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

0

4

10%

6m
o

20%

m
o

30%

FY
09
2n
d

40%

6m
o

50%

FY
09
1s
t6

60%

Start of Duke Neurosurgery Program

70%

FY
08
2n
d

80%

m
o

6m
o

m
o

90%

FY
08
1s
t6

FY
07
2n
d

m
o

6m
o

FY
07
1s
t6

FY
06
2n
d

FY
06
1s
t6

% Utilization

Start of Duke Neurosurgery Program

Cases (n)

6/12/2018

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

0

Elective Neurosurgery OR Utilization

Elective Neurosurgery OR Utilization

100%

0%

5

6/12/2018

70

Cases (n)

60
50
40
30
20
FY09

10

FY08
FY07

0
multiple
case days

2 case
days

FY06
3 case
days

4 case
days

70

Cases (n)

60
50
40
30
20
FY09

10

FY08
FY07

0
multiple
case days

2 case
days

FY06
3 case
days

4 case
days

70

Cases (n)

60
50
40
30
20
FY09

10

FY08
FY07

0
multiple
case days

2 case
days

FY06
3 case
days

4 case
days

6

6/12/2018

2500

163,000
153,000

New Admits

143,000

Total Surgical Cases
2100

133,000
1900

123,000
113,000
103,000
93,000
83,000

1700

1500

Total Surgical Cases (n)

2300

Initiation of Duke Project

Admissions (n)

Total Admits

1300

73,000

1100

FY06

FY07

FY08

FY09

2500

163,000
153,000

New Admits

143,000

Total Surgical Cases
2100

133,000
1900

123,000
113,000
103,000
93,000
83,000

1700

1500

Total Surgical Cases (n)

2300

Initiation of Duke Project

Admissions (n)

Total Admits

1300

73,000

1100

FY06

FY07

FY08

FY09

2500

163,000
153,000

New Admits

143,000

Total Surgical Cases
2100

133,000
1900

123,000
113,000
103,000
93,000
83,000

1700

1500

Total Surgical Cases (n)

2300

Initiation of Duke Project

Admissions (n)

Total Admits

1300

73,000

1100

FY06

FY07

FY08

FY09

7

6/12/2018

Uganda Neurosurgery Training Program:
Co-Directors: Dr. Michael Muhumuza and Professor Michael Haglund
Duke Neurosurgery Curriculum and East African NSTP Curriculum
Start first two Ugandan residents Aug 2009: Dr. Obiga and Dr. Muhindo,
Second set of two residents started August 2012
MMed Neurosurgery at Makerere University, Fall 2018
Currently 5 more in program, 2 starting summer 2018, total 7 residents
Uganda East African Neurosurgery Training Program: Twinning
Uganda residents spend one month at Duke observing in year 4 COSECSA
Duke Neurosurgery Residents spend one week to 1 month Uganda PGY-5/6

Before new Neurosurgery Theater:
Neurosurgeons operate 2 days/wk
Trauma cases build up on Ward 3A
Elective cases best for resident
training pushed off for
clearing Ward 3A trauma

Hope to build capacity and training
by building new NSU Theater

8

6/12/2018

Mulago gets Shs540m brain theatre

Dr. Michael Haglund shows Health Minister Christine
Ondoa the new equipment at the theatre.
January 14, 2013

9

6/12/2018

Operating Theater #4: Alex Muhindo, Professor
Haglund
Thursday Case #7

10

6/12/2018

Duke Global Neurosurgery..
..training Ugandans in Uganda

TRAINING: 7 Neurosurgeons in Uganda 2013 Trained
5 graduates, 7 more in training,
Goal: 50 neurosurgeons by 2030

COSECSA/ MMed TRAINED NEUROSURGEONS

V
I
S
I
O
N

2023
2020
2025
2024
2026

2013

2022

2022

2013

2016

50 Neurosurgeons for 62 million
1 NSU for 1.24 million

2
0
3
0

COSECSATrained
TRAINED
300 General Surgeons
by NEUROSURGEONS
50 Neurosurgeons

V
I
S
I
O
N

2025

2025

2030
2025

2018
2023

2025
2025

2030

2030

2017
2020

2030

2025

2030
2030

2022
2025

2030

2030
2025

2021
2021

2030

2030

2024
2021
2030

2025

2030

2025
2030

2021

2021

2030
2023

2019
2022

2024

2021
2030

2023
2021

2030
2021

2024

2030

2024

2024

2022
2020

2011

2011

2030

2030

2023

2030

2030
2030

2021

2030
2020

2015
2016

2020

2
0
3
0

2030
2030
2021

350 NSU trauma surgeons for 62 million
1 NSU trauma for 171,000 people

11

6/12/2018

The New Vision for Global Neurosurgery

June 28, 2014
Meeting with new Chair of Neurosurgery,
John Sampson, MD, PhD, MHS, MBA

12

6/12/2018

Published/Accepted (October 2014 – December 2015): 15 manuscripts
1. High Road Utilizers Surveys Compared to Police Data for Road Traffic Crash Hotspot Localization in Rwanda and Sri Lanka.
Staton C, De Silva V, Krebs E, Andrade L, Rulisa S, Mallawaarachchi B, Jin K, Vissoci J, Ostbye T. BMC Public Health acceptance
13Dec2015
2. Road Traffic Injury Prevention Initiatives: a systematic review and metasummary of effectiveness in low and middle income
countries Staton CA, Vissoci JRN, Gong E, Toomey N, Wafula R, Abdelgadir J, Zhou Y, Liu C, Pei F, Zick B, Ratliff C, Rotich C,
Jadue N, Andrade L, von Isenburg M, Hocker M.Plos One acceptance 18Nov 2015 (Output of Global Injuries Course)
3. Building Neurosurgical capacity in low and middle income countries Anthony Fuller, Tu Tran, Michael Muhumuza, Michael M.
Haglund Published online: November 3, 2015, eNeurologicalSci.
4. Surgeons OverSeas Assessment of Surgical Need (SOSAS) Uganda: update for household survey. Fuller A, Butler E, Tran T,
Makumbi F, Luboga S, Muhumuza C, Chipman J, Groen R, Gupta S, Kushner A, Galukande M, Haglund M. World Journal of
Surgery 2015 Dec, 39(12):2900
5. A prospective registry evaluating the epidemiology and clinical care of Traumatic Brain Injury patients presenting to a Regional
Referral Hospital in Moshi, Tanzania: challenges and the way forward. Staton, Msilanga, Kiwango, Vissoci, Lester, Hocker,
Gerardo, Mvungi Int J Inj Contr Saf Promot. 2015 Aug 4:1-9. PMID: 26239625
6. Burden of Surgical Conditions in Uganda: Pilot Study of a Population-Based Survey in Wakiso District, Uganda. Butler E, Tran T,
Fuller A, Makumbi F, Luboga S, Kisakye S, Haglund M, Chipman J, Galukande M. Surgery. 2015 Sep;158(3):764-72. doi:
10.1016/j.surg.2015.05.011. Epub 2015 Jun 16. PMID: 26088920
7. Distribution and characteristics of severe traumatic brain injury at Mulago National Referral Hospital in Uganda.Tran TM, Fuller AT,
Kiryabwire J, Mukasa J, Muhumuza M, Ssenyojo H, Haglund MM.World Neurosurg. 2015 Mar;83(3):269-77. doi:
10.1016/j.wneu.2014.12.028. Epub 2014 Dec 19. PMID: 25529531
8. Central nervous system tumor distribution at a tertiary referral center in Uganda. Hatef J, Adamson C, Obiga O, Taremwa B,
Ssenyojo H, Muhumuza M, Haglund M, Schroeder K. World Neurosurg. 2014 Sep-Oct; 82(3-4):258-65. doi:
10.1016/j.wneu.2014.06.040. Epub 2014 Jun 19. PMID: 24953304 Accepted with revisions.
9. Quality of the Development of Traumatic Brain Injury Clinical Practice Guidelines: A Systematic Review
Patel, Abraham, Reid, Tran, Toomey, Vissoci, Rodrigues, Viera, Gerardo, Euker, Mvungi, Staton
Accepted with revisions to PLoS One
10. Qualitative Evaluation of Trauma Delays in Road Traffic Injury Patients in Maringa, Brazil. Patel A, Vissoci JRN, Hocker M, Molina
E, Morales Gil N, Staton C Accepted with minor revisions to PloS One

DGNN Google Docs on April 27, 2018,

48 manuscripts in 24 months

13

6/12/2018

Neurosurgical Camp
Mbarara, Uganda
2016

Uganda Neurosurgery
Residency
Mbarara, Uganda
April 2016

Thanking Julie and other faculty
Put in grants for Bass, others,
UCB-Belgium grant, Nuvasive
Grant
Duke University Bass Foundation
Research Group
Kampala, Uganda
July 2016

14

6/13/2018

Spinal Surgery in Ghana:
How We Create A Center of Excellence
O. Boachie-Adjei, M.D. DSc.
President and Founder FOCOS
CEO, Medical Director and Surgeon in Chief
FOCOS Hospital
Past President
Scoliosis Research Society
Prof. Orthopedic Surgery
Weill Medical College of Cornell University
Chief Emeritus Scoliosis Service
Hospital For Special Surgery, New York

Author’s Disclosure Information
Oheneba Boachie-Adjei, MD
DePuy Spine, (a,b,e)
a) Grants/Research
K2M, (a,b,d)
Support
b) Consultant
Weigao Co (b,c)
c) Stock/Shareholder
d)
e)

Speakers’ Bureau
Other Financial Support

Global Health and Orthopedics
– Ranking of major causes of death and disability (%
DALYs)
• Cardiovascular and circulatory diseases 11.8%
• All neoplasms 7.6%
• Mental and behavioural disorders 7.4%

• Musculoskeletal disorders 6.8%
The fourth greatest impact on the health of the world
population, considering both death and disability (DALYs)
(Lancet 15 December 2012)

1

6/13/2018

FOCOS Orthopaedic Hospital
MISSION: To provide optimum orthopaedic
care and improve quality of life in Ghana and
other countries

VISSION: A Sustainable infrastructure
for state of the art orthopaedic care and
education.

Challenges
•
•
•
•

Human Resources
Finances
Infrastructure
Complex Orthopedic and medical
conditions
• Sustainability

Human Resource Challenge

2

6/13/2018

USA, Mexico, Argentina. Spain, Italy, Norway, Japan, Turkey, Australia
,India, Nigeria, Sierra Leone, New. Zealand, Kenya, Greece

Funding Challenge
• Ghana fares poorly among African and
global averages for total Expenditure on
health.
• The average Ghanaian cannot afford
major orthopedic surgical care and the
NHIS doesn't cover such surgical
services.

Fee For service and sponsorship program via
Fundraising (30% patients subsidized)

3

6/13/2018

Health Expenditure Indicators 2014
Health Expenditure Indicators
Ghana Value

No

Indicator

1

Total Expenditure on health as % of gross domestic product ( 2014)

Africa Average

Global Average

5.5

10.0

47.8

60.1

52.2

39.9

10.0

15.5

60.1

45.5

107

1057

51

635

3.6

2

General government expenditure on health as % of total
expenditure on health (2014)

3

Private expenditure on health as % of total expenditure on health
(2014)
General government expenditure on health as % of total
government expenditure ( 2014)

4
5

Out-of-pocket expenditure on health as % of private expenditure on
health(2014)

6

Per Capita total expenditure on health at average exchange rate
(US$) (2014)

7

Per capita government expenditure on health at average exchange
rate (US$) (2014)

59.8

40
7.0
67

58

35

FOCOS Funding strategies
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Government Seed Grant
FOCOS-MOH CO-Consignment initiatives for imports
International Volunteerism
International Multi-industry partnership
Global Private donors and Benefactors
Private foundation sponsorships of patients
FOCOS USA GRANTS
Private Loans

Global Partners

4

6/13/2018

STATE OF THE ART HOSPITAL

FOCOS Surgical THEATRE
• Twin operating theaters with state of the art equipment
– Advanced anaesthesia machines, cell savers, neuro-monitoring devices, Carms, high definition cameras.
•

Headed by a qualified perioperative nurse manager

INTENSIVE CARE UNIT/RECOVERY
•
•
•

Full coverage by anesthetists and 5 critical care nurses
A 6 bed unit with patient nurse ratio of 2:1 when in full capacity
All the essential equipment of a first class ICU including ventilators, monitors,
defibrillators, perfusers, infusion pumps and other critical care equipment in
optimum working condition

5

6/13/2018

LAB, Phisiotherapy and Radiology
Manned by qualified biomedical scientists , laboratory technician
•

Fully automated with capacity to do most investigations
• hematological analysis,
• serologies ,blood banking and biochemistries.

Pharmacy/Nutrition and Dietetics
The pharmacy is manned by
•

•
•

One (1)Senior Pharmacist and Two (2)Pharmacy Technicians
It offers a full complement of various classes of drugs available to patients
Staffed by qualified nutritionists/dietician Develops meal plans to suit individual
patient needs including nutritional rehabilitation for our malnourished patients

6

6/13/2018

Types of Surgery
5%
22%

Spine cases
(Degenerative)

15%

Spine cases (Deformity)

39%

19%

Halo traction
Major joint cases
Trauma cases

COUNTRIES
OF ORIGIN
OF FOCOS PATIENTS
IN-PATIENTS
(21 countries)
Africa
D.R.C
Ethiopia
Gambia
Ghana
Liberia
Niger
Nigeria
Sierra Leone
Tanzania
Togo
Uganda
Zambia

Europe
Albania
Russia

Others
Canada
China
Haiti
India
Philippines
Uruguay
USA

COUNTRIES OF ORIGIN OF FOCOS PATIENTS

SS063
33F
Progressive back pain and difficulty standing and walking
Tuberculous Spondylitis:

7

6/13/2018

Posterior decompression PLIF PSSI ,

FOCOS Nutritional Pathways
• Nutrition status is a significant factor in the perioperative
care of the orthopedic patient
• 90% orthopedic patients from Ethiopia seen at the
department were undernourished or small for their age
• Early identification of patients who are malnourished or
at risk is essential which leads to timely nutrition
interventions

PEDIATRIC PATIENTS CHANGE IN WEIGHT
10.71%
7.14%
42.86%

WT GAIN≥1KG
WT GAIN≤ 1KG
WTMAINTANCE
WT LOSS≤1KG

39.29%

8

6/13/2018

FOCOS RISK SCORE

FOCOS Traction, Feeding and surgical, program

9

6/13/2018

140°

178°

AIS Kyphoscoliosis
Severe and rigid

4 months HGT, PSF PCO, Thoracoplasty and SSI
Balanced Correction

10

6/13/2018

Dia8YM : NF, Cervical Kyphosis / Dislocation, Quadriplegia
ASIA –A C6 level

3 years post op

Procedure: ASF C3-C7, Corpectomy C4-C6, Fibular Strut graft C3-C7,
Instrumentation C2-T1

11

6/13/2018

ENL968
•
•
•

57F

12-05-1960

NG

A known case of multiple myeloma with Myelopathy
She previously had T10 Corpectomy + ASF T9-T11, PSF T7-L1 done in 2015.
Two years Post op she was noticed to have collapsed L2 Vertebra and subsequently had
Extension of PSF T11-S1.
She currently presents with complaints of neck pain and upper back pain as well as
occasional numbness in both hands.
2018 Collapsed C3 Treated with PSF C2-T5

•
•

Patient Details
Date

Comment

Ht (cm)

Wt (kg)

BMI

09-03-2015

Pre-op

WCB

WCB

WCB

21-09-2015

6 mo

155.3

61.7

25.6

26-09-2016

1 yr

155.3

72.2

29.9

27-06-2017

2 yr

153.5

58.9

25

19-02-2018

3yr

155.3

72.3

30

Oncology Patients

• Past Medical History:
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.

Appendicectomy (1973)
3 Cervical Cerclage
T10 Corpectomy + ASF T9-T11, PSF
T7-L1
6 Cycle of Chemotherapy for
multiple myeloma
Hypertensive

• Medications:
I.
II.

Exforge 10/160mg
Tramadol

2015

2017

12

6/13/2018

2018 Collapsed C3

Op Note: 21-02-18
•
•

•

Diagnosis: Collapsed C2 and T1
Vertebra
Procedure: PCF C2-T5, C7/T1
Foraminotomies Bonegraft (Local +
Allograft.
Complications: None

SCOLIOSIS CORRECTION BY REMOTE CONTROL
MAGEC: Only Center in West Africa

Donation by San Diego Spine Foundation

13

6/13/2018

When Life Throws You a Curve FOCOS will Help Straighten It

THANK YOU

www.focoshospitalgh.com
www.orthofocos.org

14

Spinal Trauma
in Tanzania
Roger Härtl, MD

Professor of Neurosurgery
Director of Spinal Surgery
Director of the Weill Cornell Center for Comprehensive
Spine Care
Department of Neurosurgery
Weill-Cornell Medical College
New York, NY
USA

“Surgery is the neglected stepchild
of global public health”

• 45-50 million people
–
–
–
–

>100 tribes
45% Muslim
45% Christian
Tribal religions

• Economy
– Agriculture, Service industry, mining, industry
– Avg. salary $60-70/month

1

Photographs by Andre Liohn

Photographs by Andre Liohn

2

3

4

Why Does Surgery Matter?

• 5 billion people do not have access to surgical and
anaesthesia care
• 143 million additional surgical procedures are
needed
• Investing in surgical services in LMICs is affordable,
saves lives, and promotes economic growth
• Surgery is an “indivisible, indispensable part of
health care

Questions
•
•
•
•
•
•

How can we have an impact from overseas?
Limited time – 1 week/year…
Limited resources
Cultural barriers
Language barriers
Do our goals, priorities, expectations align?
– Who is right, who is wrong?

• Fragmented groups in NA & Europe
– little coordination

• Communication challenges: Equipment,
WIFI

Weill Cornell Neurosurgery Initiative

Definition of achievable goals
• To…
– assess the current management of neurosurgical
diseases
– develop a close network that fosters exchange, teaching
and communication
– train physicians and health care workers in best
management practices
– implement stepwise and reasonable changes that will
improve neurosurgical care

5

7-point SUSTAINABLE
Weill Cornell Global Neurosurgery Initiative
1.Yearly visits to teach & train
2.Yearly Neurosurgery symposium
in Tanzania
3.Observational fellowship at Weill
Cornell: TZ→ Cornell 6 fellows so
far
4.One year Global Neurosurgery
Fellowship Cornell → TZ
5.Clinical research
6.Weekly Skype conferences
7.Publications

Maria Santos

Andreas Leidinger

•
•
•
•
•
•

2011
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017

6

Images by Andre Liohn

Neurosurgical diseases
• Neurotrauma
• Spinal infections
• Congenital malformations
• Hydrocephalus

7

Study Objectives
• Prospective collection of data of all
spinal trauma admitted to MOI.
• To:
–
–
–
–

Describe the general demographics
Understand the overall management and patient flow
Identify bottlenecks and critical points
Identify deficits and aspects in need of foreign
support
– Assess surgical outcome

Muhimbili Orthopedic
Institute (MOI)

From 2015-2017

Data Collection Tools

8

Demographics & Epidemiology
• n= 180 ST patients collected
• GENDER
- Male 149 (82.8%)
- Female 31 (17.2%)
• AGE: 35.7± 12 years old
Mechanism of Injury
60
50
40
30
20
10

MVA, 52

1.

Falls >3mt,
40

Motorcycle,
29
Pedestrian,
17

Primarily affects young
males

Falls <3mt,
Blunt object,
19
15
Sharp object,
Other, 5
3

2.

High incidence of falling
from heights

0

3.

Low incidence of ST
secondary to violence

Few hospitals
Long waiting list
Distance

Referral
time
(days)

<100km

1

100-200km

7

200-500km

11

36

500-1000km

8

32

1000+km

9

Averange
time

n

55

Dar es
Salaam

2

Regions

5

7.09

Three neurosurgical centers:
KMCM (Moshi), Muhimbili (Dar es Salaam) and NED Institute
(Zanzibar).

Results: Surgery

Factors associated with
shorter time to surgery
ICU Stay (p=0.252)
AO Type C (p=0.504)

40% of all patients received surgery.
◦ 45% of all complete injury patients.
◦ 36% of incomplete injury patients.

MVA accident as mechanism of
injury (p=0.493)

Average time to surgery: 28 days.
1.

No patient received surgery within 24 hrs.

2.

Time to surgery for patients with incomplete
injuries was 36 days versus 30 days for those
with complete injuries.

3.

90% of incomplete injuries that arrived within
24 hours post trauma did not receive surgery
within one week.

9

Results: Primary Outcome
Factors related to positive
change in AIS Grade
Shorter time to surgery

•Overall, surgery was the
only factor associated with
improvement in AIS score
from admission to discharge
(p<0.003).

Surgery (p=0.003)
Younger age
Falling mechanism <3mts
Private insurance

AIS Improvement at
discharge (p=0.03)

Mortality
(p=0.007)

Surgery Group

21.4%

1.6%

Conservative Group

8.2%

16.1%

C3-C6 CERVICAL REDUCTION AND FUSION +
C4-C6 DECOMPRESSION WITH CORTICAL
SCREWS.

• Patient was operated 12 days after
arrival.
• Postoperatively:
– Patient kept with soft neck collar
– Started physiotherapy 5 days after the
surgery

• Total admission: 32 days
• Complications: NONE

• ON DISCHARGE:
– ASIA C

10

Costs and Financing
• Private patients: 2322.2 USD
• Public status: 873.0 USD.
• Private patients were more likely
to receive surgery (57%) compared
to public patients (37.7%, p=0.088).

Hospital Bed

ICU Bed

X-ray

CT/MRI

Surgical
table

Lumbar screw
(unit)

Public

4.47 USD/day

13.40 USD/day

11.17 USD

70-93 USD

89.3 USD

69 USD

Private

33.5 USD/day

53.60 USD/day

11.17 USD

70-93 USD

670 USD

69 USD

NHIF

2188 USD flat rate inclusive of all expenses (medication, hospital bed, ICU
bed, laboratory workups, imaging, surgery, surgical implants and
rehabilitation.)

Complications

• Mortality (8.8%)
• Complications:

– Pressure ulcers (19.2 %)
– Wound infection (2.6 %)

Pressure Ulcer
Grading
60

47.1
32.4

40
20

11.8

8.8

0
I

II

III

IV

Longer waiting lists and lack of
human resources contribute to
pressure ulcers like this 43 year old
male suffering an ASIA A lesion
after MVA.

• Mortality (%) was associated with cervical injuries (p=0.001)
and complete lesions (p=0.016)
• Physiotherapy was done for 87.5% of patients.

11

Conclusion
• Surgery matters
– “Investing in surgical services in LMICs is affordable, saves
lives, and promotes economic growth” LANCET

• Surgical training and education takes time and
happens “one-on-one”
• Identify champion surgeons
• Weill Cornell Neurosurgery SUSTAINABLE Model To
Maximize impact:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Regular visits
Courses
Permanent fellowships in TZ
3 months fellowships in NYC
Research:
1. collect data and measure impact

6. Skype calls: communication
7. Publications

http://weillcornellbrainandspine.org/tanzania

12



Source Exif Data:
File Type                       : PDF
File Type Extension             : pdf
MIME Type                       : application/pdf
Linearized                      : No
Page Count                      : 40
Language                        : en-US
Tagged PDF                      : Yes
XMP Toolkit                     : 3-Heights(TM) XMP Library 4.9.17.0 (http://www.pdf-tools.com)
Title                           : MergedFile
Creator                         : BilskyM
Format                          : application/pdf
Creator Tool                    : Microsoft® PowerPoint® 2016
Create Date                     : 2018:06:11 00:35:52-07:00
Modify Date                     : 2018:06:13 13:42:42-04:00
Metadata Date                   : 2018:06:13 13:42:42-04:00
Document ID                     : uuid:6901CFE9-86CD-4D74-8C06-27F64744D9CE
Instance ID                     : urn:uuid:799e670a-d38b-4fb4-ba0a-caf47289aa77
PDF Version                     : 1.7
Producer                        : 3-Heights(TM) PDF Merge Split API 4.9.17.0 (http://www.pdf-tools.com)
Part                            : 3
Conformance                     : A
Author                          : BilskyM
EXIF Metadata provided by EXIF.tools

Navigation menu